High-threshold mechanosensitive and mechanoinsensitive (“silent”) nociceptors have similar electrical thresholds for transcutaneous sine wave stimulation at 4 Hz that selectively activates cutaneous C nociceptors in human skin. Their fundamentally different functions particularly in chronic pain warrant differential stimulation protocols. We used transcutaneously delivered slow depolarizing stimuli (half-sine, 500 ms duration, 0.01-1 mA) in humans to assess intensity–response relations for the induction of pain psychophysically and recorded activation of mechanosensitive and silent nociceptors in healthy volunteers by microneurography. Differential C-fiber activation was confirmed in single-fiber recordings in pig allowing for stimulation amplitudes up to 10 mA. Perception and pain thresholds to half-sine wave pulses were 0.06 ± 0.03 mA and 0.18 ± 0.1 mA, respectively, and caused pain in an amplitude-dependent manner (n = 24). When matched for pain intensity, only sine wave stimulation induced an instant widespread axon reflex erythema (n = 10). In human microneurography, half-sine stimulation activated mechanosensitive nociceptors (n = 13), but only one of 11 silent nociceptors. In pig skin, the amplitude-dependent activation of mechanosensitive nociceptors was confirmed (0.2-1 mA, n = 28), and activation thresholds for most silent nociceptors (n = 13) were found above 10 mA. Non-nociceptive low-threshold mechanosensitive C fibers (n = 14) displayed lower activation thresholds for half-sine wave stimuli with an amplitude-dependent discharge increase between 0.01 and 0.1 mA. We conclude that transcutaneous electrical stimulation with 500-ms half-sine wave pulses between 0.2 and 1 mA causes amplitude-dependent pain by preferential activation of mechanosensitive C nociceptors.

Pronounced activity-dependent slowing of conduction has been used to characterize mechano-insensitive, "silent" nociceptors and might be due to high expression of Na V 1.8 and could, therefore, be characterized by their tetrodotoxin-resistance (TTX-r). Nociceptor-class specific differences in action potential characteristics were studied by: (i) in vitro calcium imaging in single porcine nerve growth factor (NGF)-responsive neurites; (ii) in vivo extracellular recordings in functionally identified porcine silent nociceptors; and (iii) in vitro patch-clamp recordings from murine silent nociceptors, genetically defined by nicotinic acetylcholine receptor subunit alpha-3 (CHRNA3) expression. Porcine TTX-r neurites (n = 26) in vitro had more than twice as high calcium transients per action potential as compared to TTX-s neurites (n = 18). In pig skin, silent nociceptors (n = 14) characterized by pronounced activity-dependent slowing of conduction were found to be TTX-r, whereas polymodal nociceptors were TTX-s (n = 12) and had only moderate slowing. Mechano-insensitive cold nociceptors were also TTX-r but showed less activity-dependent slowing than polymodal nociceptors. Action potentials in murine silent nociceptors differed from putative polymodal nociceptors by longer duration and higher peak amplitudes. Longer duration AP in silent murine nociceptors linked to increased sodium load would be compatible with a pronounced activity-dependent slowing in pig silent nociceptors and longer AP durations could be in line with increased calcium transients per action potential observed in vitro in TTX-resistant NGF responsive porcine neurites. Even though there is no direct link between slowing and TTX-resistant channels, the results indicate that axons of silent nociceptors not only differ in their receptive but also in their axonal properties.

Key points C‐nociceptors are generally assumed to have a low maximum discharge frequency of 10–30 Hz. However, only mechano‐insensitive ‘silent’ C‐nociceptors cannot follow electrical stimulation at 5 Hz (75 pulses) whereas polymodal C‐nociceptors in the pig follow stimulation at up to 100 Hz without conduction failure. Sensitization by nerve growth factor increases the maximum following frequency of ‘silent’ nociceptors in pig skin and might thereby contribute in particular to intense pain sensations in chronic inflammation. A distinct class of C‐nociceptors with mechanical thresholds >150 mN resembles ‘silent’ nociceptors at low stimulation frequencies in pigs and humans, but is capable of 100 Hz discharge and thus is suited to encode painfulness of noxious mechanical stimuli. Abstract Using extracellular single‐fibre recordings from the saphenous nerve in pig in vivo, we investigated peak following frequencies (5–100 Hz) in different classes of C‐nociceptors and their modulation by nerve growth factor. Classes were defined by sensory (mechano‐sensitivity) and axonal characteristics (activity dependent slowing of conduction, ADS). Mechano‐insensitive C‐nociceptors (CMi) showed the highest ADS (34% ± 8%), followed only 66% ± 27% of 75 pulses at 5 Hz and increasingly blocked conduction at higher frequencies. Three weeks following intradermal injections of nerve growth factor, peak following frequency increased specifically in the sensitized mechano‐insensitive nociceptors (20% ± 16% to 38% ± 23% response rate after 72 pulses at 100 Hz). In contrast, untreated polymodal nociceptors with moderate ADS (15.2% ± 10.2%) followed stimulation frequencies of 100 Hz without conduction failure (98.5% ± 6%). A distinct class of C‐nociceptors was exclusively sensitive to strong forces above 150 mN. This class had a high ADS (27.2% ± 7.6%), but displayed almost no propagation failure even at 100 Hz stimulation (84.7% ± 17%). Also, among human mechanosensitive nociceptors (n = 153) those with thresholds above 150 mN (n = 5) showed ADS typical of silent nociceptors. C‐fibres with particularly high mechanical thresholds and high following frequency form a distinct nociceptor class ideally suited to encode noxious mechanical stimulation under normal conditions when regular silent nociceptors are inactive. Sensitization by nerve growth factor increases maximum discharge frequency of silent nociceptors, thereby increasing the frequency range beyond their physiological limit, which possibly contributes to excruciating pain under inflammatory conditions.