A cycloaddition–fragmentation sequence from benzene oxide and a nitroso- or azo-dienophile was investigated as a tool for access to highly substituted cyclohexene oxide derivatives. Alkyl lithium-promoted fragmentation of the cycloadducts led to the cyclic derivatives after 1,4- or 1,2-addition of a second equivalent of the lithium reagent. New fragmentation processes were observed when using non-nucleophilic bases of highly hindered alkyl lithium reagents. All reactions proceeded with complete stereocontrol.