Introduction Updated guidelines published by the National Institute for Health and Care Excellence in 2015 widened the referral criteria for the two week wait (2WW) pathway for suspected lower gastrointestinal cancer, in an attempt to increase early diagnosis. The aim of this study was to evaluate the compliance of referrals received via the (2WW) pathway for suspected lower gastrointestinal cancer. Method We conducted a retrospective study which utilised a local cancer registry to identify all patients who had been referred to United Lincolnshire Hospitals Trust over a two-month period. Electronic patient records were checked to establish whether patients fulfilled the 2015 referral criteria. Results Out of 615 patients referred, 51 (8%) had colorectal cancer. 92 (15%) referrals did not meet the criteria for the 2WW pathway. Whether or not the referral was ‘appropriate’ had no significant effect on the diagnoses of bowel cancer (X2 = .003, p>.05). Conclusions 16% of all referrals did not meet criteria. This may appear as an inefficient use of resources, however there was no difference in rates of cancer between appropriate and inappropriate referrals. The referral criteria are likely to evolve over the course of time, and perhaps clinicians’ judgement should be taken into account.