No abstract

Watershed models have gradually been adapted to support both decision and policy making for global environmental pollution control. In this study, two watershed models with different complexity, the Soil and Water Assessment Tool (SWAT) and the Generalized Watershed Loading Function (GWLF), were applied in two catchments in data scarce China, namely the Tunxi and the Hanjiaying basins with contrasting climatic conditions (humid and semi-arid, respectively). The performances of both models were assessed via comparison between simulated and measured monthly streamflow, sediment yield, and total nitrogen. Time series plots as well as four statistical measures (the coefficient of determination (R 2 ), the Nash-Sutcliffe efficiency (NSE), percent bias (PBIAS), and RMSE (root mean square error)-observations standard deviation ratio (RSR)) were used to estimate the performance of both models. The results show that both models were generally able to simulate monthly streamflow, sediment, and total nitrogen loadings during the simulation period. However, SWAT performed better for detailed representations, while GWLF could produce much better average values of the observed data. Thus, GWLF offers a user-friendly prospective alternative watershed model that requires little input data and that is applicable for areas where the input data required for SWAT are not always available. SWAT is more suitable for projects that require high accuracy and offers an advantage when measured data are scarce.

Best management practices (BMPs) are an effective way to control water pollution. However, identification of the optimal distribution and cost-effect of BMPs provides a great challenge for watershed policy makers. In this paper, a semi-distributed, low-data, and robust watershed model, the Revised Generalized Watershed Loading Function (RGWLF), is improved by adding the pollutant attenuation process in the river channel and a bank filter strips reduction function. Three types of pollution control measures—point source wastewater treatment, bank filter strips, and converting farmland to forest—are considered, and the cost of each measure is determined. Furthermore, the RGWLF watershed model is coupled with a widely recognized multi-objective optimization algorithm, the non-dominated sorting genetic algorithm II (NSGAII), the combination of which is applied in the Luanhe watershed to search for spatial BMPs for dissolved nitrogen (DisN). Fifty scenarios were finally selected from numerous possibilities and the results indicate that, at a minimum cost of 9.09 × 107 yuan, the DisN load is 3.1 × 107 kg and, at a maximum cost of 1.77 × 108 yuan, the total dissolved nitrogen load is 1.31 × 107 kg; with the no-measures scenario, the DisN load is 4.05 × 107 kg. This BMP optimization model system could assist decision-makers in determining a scientifically comprehensive plan to realize cost-effective goals for the watershed.

No abstract

The Luan River is one of the main rivers entering the Bohai Sea, and the Baohe River is a major tributary of the Luan River. Determining the contribution of pollution sources in the watershed where the upstream river enters the sea is a prerequisite for formulating environmental management measures in the sea area. Facts have proved that the model is an effective tool to determine the main environmental targets, especially in the analysis of pollution sources in the watershed. This paper uses the General Watershed Load Function (GWLF) model to simulate the monthly streamflow, dissolved nitrogen (DisN) load and dissolved phosphorus (DisP) load in the Baohe River Watershed from 2006 to 2014, and the contribution ratio of each pollution source in the source allocation of nitrogen and phosphorus load is emphasized. The application of the model shows the effectiveness of planning nitrogen and phosphorus management strategies for decision-makers, and provides a certain decision-making reference for pollution control in the watershed into the sea.