BACKGROUND: Several authors have hypothesized that adverse drug events (ADEs) upon switching from reference biologics to biosimilar products are related to the nocebo effect. However, a thorough and current review of the existing literature has not been conducted. OBJECTIVE: To evaluate if patient and/or physician knowledge of a switch from a reference biologic product to a biosimilar product was associated with an increase in ADEs likely to be susceptible to the nocebo effect.METHODS: Studies reporting efficacy and safety outcomes of a switch from a reference product to a biosimilar product were reviewed. Biologics with FDA-approved biosimilars in the United States were considered for review, including adalimumab, bevacizumab, etanercept, and infliximab. Studies were identified by searching controlled vocabulary (e.g., MeSH terms) and keywords within MEDLINE (via PubMed) and Embase. Descriptive statistics were used to quantify subjective and objective complications in doubleblinded and single-blinded or open-label studies.RESULTS: Thirty-one trials including 3,271 patients were reviewed in the full analysis. Median discontinuation rates for any reason were 14.3% (range = 0.0-33.3) in open-label studies compared with 6.95% (range = 5.2-11.0) in double-blinded studies. Discontinuation rates for ADEs were 5.6% (range = 0.0-24.2) in open-label studies versus 3.1% (range = 2.0-5.2) in double-blinded studies, suggesting the nocebo effect does affect biosimilar adoption. Subgroup analyses of antidrug antibody (ADA) development and infusion reactions were similar between infliximab open-label and doubleblinded studies. Discontinuation rates for any reason, for ADEs, and for lack of efficacy were generally higher in infliximab open-label trials compared with double-blinded trials. Etanercept biosimilar discontinuation rates for any reason were similar between study designs; however, incidences of injection site reactions and discontinuation rates for ADEs were higher in double-blinded compared with open-label study designs.CONCLUSIONS: Current evidence is insufficient to confirm a biosimilar nocebo effect, although higher discontinuation rates in infliximab biosimilar open-label studies support this theory. Further studies are needed to evaluate the existence of a biosimilar nocebo effect.

Transporters are major determinants of the disposition of xenobiotics and endogenous chemicals in the body. Organic anion transporter 3 (Oat3) functions in the kidney and brain to remove metabolic waste, toxins, and drugs, and thus transports diverse chemicals. Some b-lactam antibiotics interact with Oat3, and penicillin G exhibits a strong dependence on Oat3 for renal elimination. However, over 80 b-lactams exist, and many have not been assessed for an interaction with Oat3. Moreover, b-lactams continue to receive U.S. Food and Drug Administration approval. This study identified new b-lactam-Oat3 interactions, provided a head-to-head comparison with Oat1, and characterized the physicochemical determinants of affinity for Oat3. Cells expressing mouse Oat3 (mOat3) and Oat1 (mOat1), and human OAT3 (hOAT3) were used to test inhibitors, and high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) was used to measure transport. Of 26 b-lactams tested, 12 were clear inhibitors of Oat3, and 14 exhibited poor interactions. Inhibitors exhibited a nearly identical rank-order of potency against mOat3 and hOAT3. Oat1 demonstrated a poor interaction with most b-lactams. The majority of Oat3 inhibitors were substrates, and there were clear physicochemical differences between inhibitors and noninhibitors. That is, inhibitors had nearly 40% fewer hydrogen bond donors (P < 0.001), a lower total polar surface area (P < 0.05), and greater lipophilicity (LogP of inhibitors, +1.41; noninhibitors, 21.54; P < 0.001). Pharmacophore mapping revealed a prohibitive hydrogen bond donor group in noninhibitors adjacent to a hydrophobic moiety that was important for binding to Oat3. These findings indicate that Oat3 recognizes lipophilic b-lactams more readily. Moreover, this study has potential implications for designing b-lactams to avoid renal accumulation or brain efflux via Oat3.

No abstract