Hoogsteen base-pairing involves a 180 degree rotation of the purine base relative to Watson-Crick base-pairing within DNA duplexes, creating alternative DNA conformations that can play roles in recognition, damage induction, and replication. Here, using Nuclear Magnetic Resonance R1ρ relaxation dispersion, we show that transient Hoogsteen base-pairs occur across more diverse sequence and positional contexts than previously anticipated. We observe sequence-specific variations in Hoogsteen base-pair energetic stabilities that are comparable to variations in Watson-Crick base-pair stability, with Hoogsteen base-pairs being more abundant for energetically less favorable Watson-Crick base-pairs. Our results suggest that the variations in Hoogsteen stabilities and rates of formation are dominated by variations in Watson-Crick base pair stability, suggesting a late transition state for the Watson-Crick to Hoogsteen conformational switch. The occurrence of sequence and position-dependent Hoogsteen base-pairs provide a new potential mechanism for achieving sequence-dependent DNA transactions.

In 1957, a unique pattern of hydrogen bonding between N3 and O4 on uracil and N7 and N6 on adenine was proposed to explain how poly(rU) strands can associate with poly(rA)-poly(rU) duplexes to form triplexes. Two years later, Karst Hoogsteen visualized such a non-canonical A-T base-pair through X-ray analysis of co-crystals containing 9-methyladenine and 1-methylthymine. Subsequent X-ray analyses of guanine and cytosine derivatives yielded the expected Watson-Crick base-pairing but those of adenine and thymine (or uridine) did not yield Watson-Crick base-pairs, instead favoring ‘Hoogsteen’ base-pairing. More than two decades ensued without experimental ‘proof’ for A-T Watson-Crick base-pairs, while Hoogsteen base-pairs continued to surface in AT-rich sequences, closing base-pairs of apical loops, in structures of DNA bound to antibiotics and proteins, damaged and chemically modified DNA, and in polymerases that replicate DNA via Hoogsteen pairing. Recently, NMR studies have shown that base-pairs in duplex DNA exists as a dynamic equilibrium between Watson-Crick and Hoogsteen forms. There is now little doubt that Hoogsteen base-pairs exist in significant abundance in genomic DNA where they can expand the structural and functional versatility of duplex DNA beyond that which can be achieved based only on Watson-Crick base-pairing. Here, we provide a historical account of the discovery and characterization of Hoogsteen base-pairs hoping that this will inform future studies exploring the occurrence and functional importance of these alternative base-pairs.

No abstract