Competition is prevalent and could be harnessed as an alternative to antibiotics

Complications arising from antibiotic-resistant bacteria are becoming one of the key issues in modern medicine. Members of drug-resistant Enterobacteriaceae spp. include opportunistic pathogens (e.g., Salmonella spp.) that are among the leading causes of morbidity and mortality worldwide. Overgrowth of these bacteria is considered a hallmark of intestinal dysbiosis. Microcins (small antimicrobial peptides) produced by some gut commensals can potentially cure these conditions by inhibiting these pathogens and have been proposed as a viable alternative to antibiotic treatment. In this proof-of-concept work, we leverage this idea to develop a genetically engineered prototype probiotic to inhibit Salmonella spp. upon exposure to tetrathionate, a molecule produced in the inflamed gut during the course of Salmonella infection. We developed a plasmid-based system capable of conferring the ability to detect and utilize tetrathionate, while at the same time producing microcin H47. We transferred this plasmid-based system to Escherichia coli and demonstrated the ability of the engineered strain to inhibit growth of Salmonella in anaerobic conditions while in the presence of tetrathionate, with no detectable inhibition in the absence of tetrathionate. In direct competition assays between the engineered E. coli and Salmonella, the engineered E. coli had a considerable increase in fitness advantage in the presence of 1 mM tetrathionate as compared to the absence of tetrathionate. In this work, we have demonstrated the ability to engineer a strain of E. coli capable of using an environmental signal indicative of intestinal inflammation as an inducing molecule, resulting in production of a microcin capable of inhibiting the organism responsible for the inflammation.

Microcin H47 (MccH47) is an antimicrobial peptide produced by some strains of Escherichia coli that has demonstrated inhibitory activity against enteric pathogens in vivo and has been heterologously overexpressed in proof-of-concept engineered probiotic applications. While most studies clearly demonstrate inhibitory activity against E. coli isolates, there are conflicting results on the qualitative capacity for MccH47 to inhibit strains of Salmonella. Here, we rectify these inconsistencies via the overexpression and purification of a form of MccH47, termed MccH47-monoglycosylated enterobactin (MccH47−MGE). We then use purified MccH47 to estimate minimum inhibitory concentrations (MICs) against a number of medically relevant Enterobacteriaceae, including Salmonella and numerous multidrug resistant (MDR) strains. While previous reports suggested that the spectrum of activity for MccH47 is quite narrow and restricted to activity against E. coli, our data demonstrate that MccH47 has broad and potent activity within the Enterobacteriaceae family, suggesting it as a candidate for further development toward treating MDR enteric infections.

No abstract

A key property of many antibiotics is that they will kill or inhibit a diverse range of microbial species. This broad-spectrum of activity has its evolutionary roots in ecological competition, whereby bacteria and other microbes use antibiotics to suppress other strains and species. However, many bacteria also use narrow-spectrum toxins, such as bacteriocins, that principally target conspecifics. Why has such a diversity in spectrum evolved? Here, we develop an evolutionary model to understand antimicrobial spectrum. Our first model recapitulates the intuition that broad-spectrum is best, because it enables a microbe to kill a wider diversity of competitors. However, this model neglects an important property of antimicrobials: They are commonly bound, sequestered, or degraded by the cells they target. Incorporating this toxin loss reveals a major advantage to narrow-spectrum toxins: They target the strongest ecological competitor and avoid being used up on less important species. Why then would broad-spectrum toxins ever evolve? Our model predicts that broad-spectrum toxins will be favored by natural selection if a strain is highly abundant and can overpower both its key competitor and other species. We test this prediction by compiling and analyzing a database of the regulation and spectrum of toxins used in inter-bacterial competition. This analysis reveals a strong association between broad-spectrum toxins and density-dependent regulation, indicating that they are indeed used when strains are abundant. Our work provides a rationale for why bacteria commonly evolve narrow-spectrum toxins such as bacteriocins and suggests that the evolution of antibiotics proper is a signature of ecological dominance.