No abstract

This paper summarises five years' experience of patient and public involvement in primary care, citing examples from the Lanark practice and Clydesdale Local Health Care Co-operative (LHCC) in Lanarkshire, Scotland. Strategic development and models which align primary care structures within a framework for patient and public involvement are described, along with barriers to implementation. Examples derived from clinical governance, health promotion and needs assessment include patient and carer involvement in significant event analysis and audit, joint training and patient-held record cards. Positive outcomes reported are effective dialogue between health professionals, patients and the public, service developments and quality improvements. The success of initiatives is retrospectively assessed against the Audit Commission's critical success factors.

GP appraisal may, in future, have to include objective and verifiable elements. This condition could be achieved by developing peer review of core areas of clinical practice. The setting for the study was two regions of NHS Education for Scotland (NES) without existing peer review systems (Figure 1). The South East region was further divided into South and East areas. A triangulation methodology was adopted to reflect the perspectives of peer reviewers, GPs submitting materials and the GPs appraising them (Figure 2). Outcomes measures included peer reviewers' feedback, learning needs identified by peer review, feedback from contributors and appraisers' perception of making judgements within GP appraisal. 1 Peer reviewers were recruited, trained and allocated to provide feedback on significant event analysis (SEA), criterion audit or video consultation submitted by professional colleagues. 2 GP appraisers voluntarily submitted materials for peer review then commented on feedback provided by peer reviewers. 3 A focus group of appraisers examined issues relating to professional judgement and national standards within appraisal. 4 All 15 peer reviewers recruited considered the project successful. Peer reviewers thought the model piloted could be delivered nationally if adequately resourced and supported by GPs. 5 Twenty six items (14 SEAs, nine audits and three videos) were submitted for peer review, which demonstrated moderate or high levels of learning need among GP participants. 6 In the focus group, most appraisers expressed difficulty making 'professional judgements' within appraisal but demonstrated a clear willingness to accept peer-reviewed material as evidence for discussion and development. Appraisers identified a range of educational material with the potential to conform to a national standard. There is potential for peer review to contribute to the development of objective and verifiable elements in GP appraisal, encouraging GPs to achieve agreed educational standards independent of the appraisal process. This small study suggests that a national system of peer review to support GP appraisal may be desirable among relevant stakeholders and should be explored further. Additional resources would clearly be required. A comparative review of different systems in other countries suggests further research is necessary to provide greater evidence of feasibility, acceptability and educational benefit of such a system in the UK.

Ecthyma contagiosum (orf) is caused by a parapox virus, which results in ulcerative stomatitis of mainly sheep and goats. The disease may be transmitted to humans through direct contact. Complications are rare in healthy individuals, who rarely report the disease. Two married, recreational sheep farmers, were bitten on their index fingers by an affected lamb. While the husband made an uneventful recovery after oral flucloxacillin, his wife was admitted to hospital with necrosis of her finger, cellulitis and lymphangitis requiring intravenous clindamycin. She subsequently developed a generalized maculo-papular rash, which was initially thought to be an adverse drug reaction, but, on hindsight, may have been erythema multiforme associated with orf. Orf is a common zoonosis, rarely reported in general practice. The disease is usually self-limiting and resolves in 6-8 weeks, but complications may occur. The diagnosis should be considered in at-risk occupational and religious groups.