In 1999 an outbreak involving 188 patients with Legionnaires' disease (LD) occurred among visitors to a flower show in the Netherlands. Two enzyme immunoassays (Binax and Biotest) and one immunochromatographic assay (Binax NOW) were tested, using urine samples from LD patients from the 1999 outbreak. Sensitivity was calculated using positive culture and/or seroconversion as the "gold standard" in outbreakrelated patients with radiographically confirmed pneumonia who fulfilled the epidemiological critera. The Binax EIA, Biotest EIA, and Binax NOW assay showed overall sensitivities of 69, 71, and 72%, respectively. When the tests were performed with concentrated urine samples, the overall sensitivities increased to 79, 74, and 81%, respectively. Using multiple logistic regression analysis with backward elimination, a statistically significant association was found between clinical severity and test sensitivity for all tests. For patients with mild LD, the test sensitivities ranged from 40 to 53%, whereas for patients with severe LD who needed immediate special medical care, the sensitivities reached 88 to 100%. These findings have major implications for the diagnostic process in patients with mild pneumonia and suggest that patients with mild pneumonia may go underdiagnosed if urine antigen tests alone are used.
Legionnaires' disease (LD) is an acute pneumonia caused byLegionella, a rod-shaped gram-negative bacillus ubiquitous in (man-made) aquatic reservoirs. Currently 43 Legionella species and 65 serogroups have been described. In the United States, over 90% of Legionnaires' disease cases are caused by Legionella pneumophila, of which 70% of strains belong to serogroup type 1 (16). Legionella spp. are responsible for 1 to 5% of cases of community-acquired pneumonia (CAP) (5). Clinically and radiographically, LD cannot be distinguished from pneumonias caused by other microbial pathogens. Because of the high mortality rate in patients with LD requiring hospitalization, early diagnosis to enable adequate antimicrobial treatment is potentially life-saving. Diagnosis of LD in patients with symptomatic pneumonia is based on culture, serologic testing, or antigen detection in urine. Isolation of Legionella from respiratory secretions is not a very sensitive diagnostic test (25 to 75% sensitivity) (15) and has the disadvantage of delay, because a positive result is not available until at least 3 days of incubation. Seroconversion is a diagnostic test with a high sensitivity and a high (serogroup-dependant) specificity, but it is of limited clinical value since it may take up to 9 weeks for patients to develop detectable antibodies (10, 13).In contrast to the other tests mentioned above, urinary antigen tests combine reasonable sensitivity and high specificity with rapid results. The reported sensitivities of both enzyme immunoassay (EIA) and immunochromatographic test (ICT) show great variation: 50 to 90% (3,7,8,19). These variations may be explained by differences in patient characteristics, the serogroup with which th...