β-Sheets have been implicated in various neurological disorders, and ∼20% of protein residues adopt a sheet conformation. Therefore, studies on the structural origin of sheet stability can provide fundamental knowledge with potential biomedical applications. Oppositely charged amino acids are frequently observed across one another in antiparallel β-sheets. Interestingly, the side chains of natural charged amino acids Asp, Glu, Arg, Lys have different numbers of hydrophobic methylenes linking the backbone to the hydrophilic charged functionalities. To explore the inherent effect of charged amino acid side chain length on antiparallel sheets, the stability of a designed hairpin motif containing charged amino acids with varying side chain lengths at non-hydrogen bonded positions was studied. Peptides with the guest position on the N-terminal strand and the C-terminal strand were investigated by NMR methods. The charged amino acids (Xaa) included negatively charged residues with a carboxylate group (Asp, Glu, Aad in increasing length), positively charged residues with an ammonium group (Dap, Dab, Orn, Lys in increasing length), and positively charged residues with a guanidinium group (Agp, Agb, Arg, Agh in increasing length). The fraction folded and folding free energy for each peptide were derived from the chemical shift deviation data. The stability of the peptides with the charged residues at the N-terminal guest position followed the trends: Asp > Glu > Aad, Dap < Dab < Orn ∼ Lys, and Agb < Arg < Agh < Agp. The stability of the peptides with the charged residues at the C-terminal guest position followed the trends: Asp < Glu < Aad, Dap ∼ Dab < Orn ∼ Lys, and Agb < Arg ∼ Agp < Agh. These trends were rationalized by thermodynamic sheet propensity and cross-strand interactions.

β-Sheets are one of the fundamental three-dimensional building blocks for protein structures. Oppositely charged amino acids are frequently observed directly across one another in antiparallel sheet structures, suggesting the importance of cross-strand ion pairing interactions. Despite the apparent electrostatic nature of ion pairing interactions, the charged amino acids Asp, Glu, Arg, Lys have different numbers of hydrophobic methylenes linking the charged functionality to the backbone. Accordingly, the effect of charged amino acid side chain length on cross-strand ion pairing interactions at lateral non-hydrogen bonded positions was investigated in a β-hairpin motif. The negatively charged residues with a carboxylate (Asp, Glu, Aad in increasing length) were incorporated at position 4, and the positively charged residues with an ammonium (Dap, Dab, Orn, Lys in increasing length) were incorporated at position 9. The fraction folded population and folding free energy were derived from the chemical shift deviation data. Double mutant cycle analysis was used to determine the interaction energy for the potential lateral ion pairs. Only the Asp/Glu-Dap interactions with shorter side chains and the Aad-Orn/Lys interactions with longer side chains exhibited stabilizing energetics, mostly relying on electrostatics and hydrophobics, respectively. This suggested the need for length matching of the interacting residues to stabilize the β-hairpin motif. A survey of a nonredundant protein structure database revealed that the statistical sheet pair propensity followed the trend Asp-Lys < Glu-Lys, also implying the need for length matching of the oppositely charged residues.

The charge-containing hydrophilic functionalities of encoded charged amino acids are linked to the backbone via different numbers of hydrophobic methylenes, despite the apparent electrostatic nature of protein ion pairing interactions. To investigate the effect of side chain length of guanidinium- and carboxylate-containing residues on ion pairing interactions, α-helical peptides containing Zbb-Xaa (i, i + 3), (i, i + 4) and (i, i + 5) (Zbb = carboxylate-containing residues Aad, Glu, Asp in decreasing length; Xaa = guanidinium residues Agh, Arg, Agb, Agp in decreasing length) sequence patterns were studied by circular dichroism spectroscopy (CD). The helicity of Aad- and Glu-containing peptides was similar and mostly pH independent, whereas the helicity of Asp-containing peptides was mostly pH dependent. Furthermore, the Arg-containing peptides consistently exhibited higher helicity compared to the corresponding Agp-, Agb-, and Agh-containing peptides. Side chain conformational analysis by molecular mechanics calculations showed that the Zbb-Xaa (i, i + 3) and (i, i + 4) interactions mainly involved the χ 1 dihedral combinations (g+, g+) and (g-, g+), respectively. These low energy conformations were also observed in intrahelical Asp-Arg and Glu-Arg salt bridges of natural proteins. Accordingly, Asp and Glu provides variation in helix characteristics associated with Arg, but Aad does not provide features beyond those already delivered by Glu. Importantly, nature may have chosen the side chain length of Arg to support helical conformations through inherent high helix propensity coupled with stabilizing intrahelical ion pairing interactions with the carboxylate-containing residues.