Novel N-tuple topological/geometric cutoffs to consider specific inter-atomic relations in the QuBiLS-MIDAS framework are introduced in this manuscript. These molecular cutoffs permit the taking into account of relations between more than two atoms by using (dis-)similarity multi-metrics and the concepts related with topological and Euclidean-geometric distances. To this end, the kth two-, three- and four-tuple topological and geometric neighbourhood quotient (NQ) total (or local-fragment) spatial-(dis)similarity matrices are defined, to represent 3D information corresponding to the relations between two, three and four atoms of the molecular structures that satisfy certain cutoff criteria. First, an analysis of a diverse chemical space for the most common values of topological/Euclidean-geometric distances, bond/dihedral angles, triangle/quadrilateral perimeters, triangle area and volume was performed in order to determine the intervals to take into account in the cutoff procedures. A variability analysis based on Shannon's entropy reveals that better distribution patterns are attained with the descriptors based on the cutoffs proposed (QuBiLS-MIDAS NQ-MDs) with regard to the results obtained when all inter-atomic relations are considered (QuBiLS-MIDAS KA-MDs - 'Keep All'). A principal component analysis shows that the novel molecular cutoffs codify chemical information captured by the respective QuBiLS-MIDAS KA-MDs, as well as information not captured by the latter. Lastly, a QSAR study to obtain deeper knowledge of the contribution of the proposed methods was carried out, using four molecular datasets (steroids (STER), angiotensin converting enzyme (ACE), thermolysin inhibitors (THER) and thrombin inhibitors (THR)) widely used as benchmarks in the evaluation of several methodologies. One to four variable QSAR models based on multiple linear regression were developed for each compound dataset following the original division into training and test sets. The results obtained reveal that the novel cutoff procedures yield superior performances relative to those of the QuBiLS-MIDAS KA-MDs in the prediction of the biological activities considered. From the results achieved, it can be suggested that the proposed N-tuple topological/geometric cutoffs constitute a relevant criteria for generating MDs codifying particular atomic relations, ultimately useful in enhancing the modelling capacity of the QuBiLS-MIDAS 3D-MDs.

BackgroundRecently, novel 3D alignment-free molecular descriptors (also known as QuBiLS-MIDAS) based on two-linear, three-linear and four-linear algebraic forms have been introduced. These descriptors codify chemical information for relations between two, three and four atoms by using several (dis-)similarity metrics and multi-metrics. Several studies aimed at assessing the quality of these novel descriptors have been performed. However, a deeper analysis of their performance is necessary. Therefore, in the present manuscript an assessment and statistical validation of the performance of these novel descriptors in QSAR studies is performed.ResultsTo this end, eight molecular datasets (angiotensin converting enzyme, acetylcholinesterase inhibitors, benzodiazepine receptor, cyclooxygenase-2 inhibitors, dihydrofolate reductase inhibitors, glycogen phosphorylase b, thermolysin inhibitors, thrombin inhibitors) widely used as benchmarks in the evaluation of several procedures are utilized. Three to nine variable QSAR models based on Multiple Linear Regression are built for each chemical dataset according to the original division into training/test sets. Comparisons with respect to leave-one-out cross-validation correlation coefficients reveal that the models based on QuBiLS-MIDAS indices possess superior predictive ability in 7 of the 8 datasets analyzed, outperforming methodologies based on similar or more complex techniques such as: Partial Least Square, Neural Networks, Support Vector Machine and others. On the other hand, superior external correlation coefficients are attained in 6 of the 8 test sets considered, confirming the good predictive power of the obtained models. For the values non-parametric statistic tests were performed, which demonstrated that the models based on QuBiLS-MIDAS indices have the best global performance and yield significantly better predictions in 11 of the 12 QSAR procedures used in the comparison. Lastly, a study concerning to the performance of the indices according to several conformer generation methods was performed. This demonstrated that the quality of predictions of the QSAR models based on QuBiLS-MIDAS indices depend on 3D structure generation method considered, although in this preliminary study the results achieved do not present significant statistical differences among them.ConclusionsAs conclusions it can be stated that the QuBiLS-MIDAS indices are suitable for extracting structural information of the molecules and thus, constitute a promissory alternative to build models that contribute to the prediction of pharmacokinetic, pharmacodynamics and toxicological properties on novel compounds.Graphical abstractComparative graphical representation of the performance of the novel QuBiLS-MIDAS 3D-MDs with respect to other methodologies in QSAR modeling of eight chemical datasetsElectronic supplementary materialThe online version of this article (doi:10.1186/s13321-016-0122-x) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

A different perspective to compute global weighted definitions of molecular descriptors from the contributions of each atom (LOVIs) or covalent bond (LOEIs) within a molecule is presented, using the generalized ordered weighted averaging - weighted averaging (GOWAWA) aggregation operator. This operator is rather different from the other norm-, mean- and statistic-based operators used up to date for the descriptors calculation from LOVIs/LOEIs. GOWAWA unifies the generalized ordered weighted averaging (GOWA) and the weighted generalized mean (WGM) functions and, in addition, it uses a smoothing parameter to assign different importance values to both functions depending on the problem under study. With the GOWAWA operator, diversity of novel global aggregations of molecular descriptors can be determined, where the influence that each atom (or covalent bond) has on the molecular characterization is taken into account. Therefore, this approach is completely different from the ones reported in the literature, where the values of LOVIs/LOEIs are considered equally important. To demonstrate the feasibility of using this operator, the QuBiLS-MIDAS descriptors (http://tomocomd.com/qubils-midas) were used and, as a result, a module was built into the corresponding software to compute them, being thus the only software reported in the literature that can be employed to determine weighted descriptors. Moreover, several modeling studies were performed on eight chemical datasets, which demonstrated that, with the GOWAWA aggregation operator, weighted QuBiLS-MIDAS descriptors that contribute to develop models with greater predictive power can be computed, if compared to the models based on the non-weighted descriptors calculated from the other operators used up to date. A non-parametric statistical assessment confirmed that the GOWAWA-based predictions are significantly superior to the others obtained. Therefore, all in all, it can be concluded that, from the results achieved, the GOWAWA operator constitutes a prominent alternative to codify relevant chemical information of the molecules, ultimately useful in improving the modeling ability of several old and recent descriptors whose definition is based on the LOVIs/LOEIs calculation.

BackgroundSeveral topological (2D) and geometric (3D) molecular descriptors (MDs) are calculated from local vertex/edge invariants (LOVIs/LOEIs) by performing an aggregation process. To this end, norm-, mean- and statistic-based (non-fuzzy) operators are used, under the assumption that LOVIs/LOEIs are independent (orthogonal) values of one another. These operators are based on additive and/or linear measures and, consequently, they cannot be used to encode information from interrelated criteria. Thus, as LOVIs/LOEIs are not orthogonal values, then non-additive (fuzzy) measures can be used to encode the interrelation among them.ResultsGeneral approaches to compute fuzzy 2D/3D-MDs from the contribution of each atom (LOVIs) or covalent bond (LOEIs) within a molecule are proposed, by using the Choquet integral as fuzzy aggregation operator. The Choquet integral-based operator is rather different from the other operators often used for the 2D/3D-MDs calculation. It performs a reordering step to fuse the LOVIs/LOEIs according to their magnitudes and, in addition, it considers the interrelation among them through a fuzzy measure. With this operator, fuzzy definitions can be derived from traditional or recent MDs; for instance, fuzzy Randic-like connectivity indices, fuzzy Balaban-like indices, fuzzy Kier–Hall connectivity indices, among others. To demonstrate the feasibility of using this operator, the QuBiLS-MIDAS 3D-MDs were used as study case and, as a result, a module was built into the corresponding software to compute them (http://tomocomd.com/qubils-midas). Thus, it is the only software reported in the literature that can be employed to determine Choquet integral-based fuzzy MDs. Moreover, regression models were created on eight chemical datasets. In this way, a comparison between the results achieved by the models based on the non-fuzzy QuBiLS-MIDAS 3D-MDs with regard to the ones achieved by the models based on the fuzzy QuBiLS-MIDAS 3D-MDs was made. As a result, the models built with the fuzzy QuBiLS-MIDAS 3D-MDs achieved the best performance, which was statistically corroborated through the Wilcoxon signed-rank test.ConclusionsAll in all, it can be concluded that the Choquet integral constitutes a prominent alternative to compute fuzzy 2D/3D-MDs from LOVIs/LOEIs. In this way, better characterizations of the compounds can be obtained, which will be ultimately useful in enhancing the modelling ability of existing traditional 2D/3D-MDs.Electronic supplementary materialThe online version of this article (10.1186/s13321-018-0306-7) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.