The existence of massive cryptic diversity in algae makes linking DNA‐based lineages to existing taxa exceedingly difficult. A better integration of historical collections into modern taxonomic research is therefore highly desirable. Using the brown algal genus Lobophora as a test case, we explore the feasibility of linking taxonomic names to clades in modern phylogenies. Despite Lobophora being a pantropical genus with probably more than 100 species, traditionally only a handful of species have been recognized. In this study we reevaluated the identity of 17 historical taxa thought to belong to Lobophora by attempting DNA amplification of herbarium material as well as specimens recently collected from the type localities (epitypes). In an attempt to assign them to Molecular Operational Taxonomic Units, the obtained sequences were integrated in a global Lobophora phylogeny based upon data derived from more than 650 specimens. Our results indicate that although five sequences were obtained from type specimens, exclusive reliance on information preserved in type specimens is problematic. Epitype material proved a more successful way forward, but this route often comes with a considerable degree of uncertainty, especially in tropical regions where the extent of sympatry among Lobophora lineages is often considerable. More problematic from a broader perspective is the fact that for 35% of historical taxa, either the type could not be traced or permission was not granted to extract DNA from the types. Such a low accessibility rate may reduce our reliance on type material and jeopardize future efforts to integrate historical taxa into a framework of a modern DNA‐based taxonomy.

Sargassum C. Agardh is one of the morphologically most complex phaeophyceaen genera and represents the most species-rich genus of the brown algal order Fucales Bory de Saint-Vincent (Phaeophyceae). The genus' classification system dates back to the 19th century and is based on observed differences in macromorphological characters. Those morphological characters may display important variation within individual species, and several authors have linked the taxonomic complexity of the genus to its highly polymorphic nature and phenotypic plasticity. Among the large choice of existing species and subspecies epithets (about 1000), identifying taxa accurately is a difficult task, often relying on authors' interpretation of short Latin diagnoses or descriptions published in local Floras. Recently, the study of individual species' morphological range and DNA phylogenies underlined inconsistencies within low taxonomic levels (sections, subsections, series and species groups). Results highlighted the weak taxonomic value of traditional characters used to classify species, and pointed out significant taxonomic issues. The four Sargassum subgenera (S. subgen. Arthrophycus, Bactrophycus, Sargassum and Phyllotrichia) are now subdivided into a total of 12 sections and further subdivisions were abandoned. Two possible new sections need to be assessed. In the present paper, we raise the hypothesis that S. subgen. Arthrophycus could be merged to S. subgen. Bactrophycus, and that S. subgen. Phyllotrichia could be transferred to the recently reinstated genus Sargassopsis Trevisan. We also propose that two sections of the S. subgen. Bactrophycus: S. sect. Halochloa and Repentia be merged. A summary of the actual classification is given along with an identification key for Sargassum subdivisions. Résumé Sargassum C. Agardh représente le genre le plus complexe et le plus riche de l'ordre des Fucales Bory de Saint-Vincent (Phaeophyceae). La classification du genre remonte au 19 ème siècle et se base sur l'observation de plusieurs caractères macromorphologiques, lesquels peuvent montrer des variations importantes au niveau intra-spécifique. Plusieurs auteurs on mis en évidence le lien existant entre la complexité taxonomique du genre et sa nature polymorphique ainsi que sa plasticité phénotypique. Ainsi parmi le large choix d'épithètes d'espèces et de sous-espèces disponible pour Sargassum (près de 1000), identifier un taxon de façon précise est une tâche difficile reposant souvent sur l'interprétation de courtes diagnoses en Latin ou de descriptions disponibles dans des Flores locales. Récemment, l'analyse combinée de la variabilité morphologique et ADN pour des espèces étudiées individuellement, ont permis de mettre en évidence des incohérences au niveau infra-générique (sections, subsections, series et groupes d'espèces). Les résultats ont souligné la faible valeur taxonomique des caractères utilisés pour classer les espèces, et mis en évidence un certain nombre de conséquences taxonomiques. Les quatre sous-genres de Sargassum (S. sub...

The species diversity of the subgenus Sargassum was reassessed for the southwestern Pacific with special focus on the Solomon Islands, Vanuatu, Fiji, and Wallis. Five taxa were recognized on the basis of morphological characters and corroborated by DNA analyses of the nuclear internal transcribed spacer 2 (ITS-2), chloroplastic partial rbcLS-operon, and mitochondrial cox3. Based on the study of diagnoses and type specimens, four taxa were identified to S. polyphyllum J. Agardh, S. polycystum C. Agardh, S. aquifolium (Turner) C. Agardh, and S. ilicifolium (Turner) C. Agardh, while one taxon remained unidentified. We present a key for identification that includes detailed descriptions of the species and illustrations of their morphological variability. In light of our findings, we propose to consider several new synonymies for S. aquifolium, S. ilicifolium, S. polycystum, and S. polyphyllum. We also include a review of Sargassum floras from Samoa, Tonga, and Nauru and discuss species distribution in the southwest and central Pacific. Finally, DNA phylogenies pointed to the polyphyly of section Acanthocarpicae and underlined the need for a new section in which to place S. polycystum, S. herporhizum Setch. et N. L. Gardner, and S. stolonifolium Phang et T. Yoshida. The new section Polycystae Mattio et Payri is described to fit species of the subgenus Sargassum with stolon-like branches.

An assessment of Sargassum in French Polynesia was done through the critical revision of the literature, type specimens, and specimens from type localities. Sargassum samples were newly collected, and four morphotypes were identified on the basis of morphological characters. Molecular analysis of the nuclear ITS2, chloroplastic partial rbcLS, and mitochondrial cox3 markers generated two clades and confirmed the recent divergence suspected between closely related species. Although 18 different epithets have been attributed to French Polynesian Sargassum since 1828, only three species are considered valid in this study. Most of these species were transferred to S. pacificum Bory, the only species present in the Society Archipelago, while S. obtusifolium J. Agardh was restricted to the Austral Archipelago, and S. echinocarpum J. Agardh was confirmed for the Austral and Gambier Archipelagos. A morphological identification key is provided, along with descriptions and illustrations for each polymorphic species. Moreover, the study of several regional collections underlined similar and low specific diversity among Sargassum populations in the southeastern Pacific. As a result of this study, we propose that S. bacciferum J. Agardh var. latiuscula Grunow, S. bisserula f. pacifica Grunow, S. boraborense (Grunow) Setch., S. mangarevense (Grunow) Setch., S. sociale (Grunow) Setch., and S. tahitense Grunow be considered as heterotypic synonyms of S. pacificum. Sargassum skottsbergii Sjöstedt, S. hawaiiensis Doty et Newhouse, S. divaricatum var. chilensis Grunow, S. obtusifolium J. Agardh f. chamberlainii Grunow, and S. obtusifolium J. Agardh f. lendigeroides Grunow are further regarded as heterotypic synonyms of S. obtusifolium.