Coincidentally, I started to review Approaches to Peacebuilding just as the United States was beginning to comprehend that the military victory in Iraq was truly the easiest (and most exciting) part of its latest world project. It was frantically changing its appointed overseers in an attempt to end the chaos that had been engendered by the military victory. And America was just about realizing what it might be facing in terms of the full drudgery involved in redeveloping Iraq onward to full democracy, peace and harmony, as well as imbedding it into the world capitalist system from the ashes of social and economic chaos.The situation in Iraq provides an interesting background against which to judge the utility of this book that purports to focus on "diverse processes and strategies for the transition from violent conflict to post-conflict reconstruction" (p. 3). As I read the book, I kept asking myself what would those who are trying to sort out Iraq have to learn from this book? The good news is that there are at least some chapters that I believe could have been productively photocopied for U.S. government administrators. The bad news, however, is that the overall lack of focus, and the prevailing terminological confusion that besets the field of conflict resolution, is unfortunately far too evident to make it seductive reading for anyone who strays into the book in the hope of finding a great deal of useful wisdom.Chapter 2, by Charles Phillipe David, is the most useful of all of the chapters. It sets out the three necessities to be faced in a postviolence stage of a conflict-that is, the need for a security transition, a democratic transition, and a socioeconomic transition-and includes a useful analysis of what is required in all three. The chapter also makes relevant needs even clearer by providing an appendix, which can be used to evaluate peacebuilding missions. This appendix represents a very useful check-
This chapter addresses some of the suggestions that are emerging from the growing field of social and behavioral psychology about how the work of peacebuilders, diplomats, the military, and others can use some of the insights noted in this book. The suggestions are not a substitute for the theories and practices that are currently in use by researchers and activists in their various fields. Rather they suggest an extra way of undertaking our analysis by taking into account the multiple lawyers of instincts and emotions that often imbue the actions of communities and peoples involved in often violent conflict. Every such analysis will of course be informed by the particular complexities of the contexts within which particular conflicts are occurring, and the security needs within that context. But by also addressing the instinctual and emotional needs of the various parties involved in conflicts, the work of peacebuilders of all hues can make their work more effective and more sustainable.
scite is a Brooklyn-based organization that helps researchers better discover and understand research articles through Smart Citations–citations that display the context of the citation and describe whether the article provides supporting or contrasting evidence. scite is used by students and researchers from around the world and is funded in part by the National Science Foundation and the National Institute on Drug Abuse of the National Institutes of Health.