This study aims to evaluate five different methodologies reported in the literature for developing fragility curves to assess the seismic performance of RC structures subjected to structural pounding. In this context, displacement-based and curvature-based fragility curves are developed. The use of probabilistic seismic demand models (PSDMs) on the fragility assessment of the pounding risk is further estimated. Linear and bilinear PSDMs are developed, while the validity of the assumptions commonly used to produce a PSDM is examined. Finally, the influence of the PSDMs’ assumptions on the derivation of fragilities for the structural pounding effect is identified. The examined pounding cases involve the interaction between adjacent RC structures that have equal story heights (floor-to-floor interaction). Results indicate that the fragility assessment of the RC structure that suffers the pounding effect is not affected by the examined methodologies when the performance level that controls the seismic behavior is exceeded at low levels of IM. Thus, the more vulnerable the structure is due to the pounding effect, the more likely that disparities among the fragility curves of the examined methods are eliminated. The use of a linear PSDM fails to properly describe the local inelastic demands of the structural RC member that suffers the impact effect. The PSDM’s assumptions are not always satisfied for the examined engineering demand parameters of this study, and thus may induce errors when fragility curves are developed. Nevertheless, errors induced due to the power law model and the homoscedasticity assumptions of the PSDM can be reduced by using the bilinear regression model.

No abstract

The effect of an intensity measure’s (IM’s) sufficiency property on the probabilistic assessment of reinforced concrete (RC) structures due to floor-to-floor structural pounding conditions is examined. In the first part of this investigation, efficiency and sufficiency properties of 23 scalar IMs are verified. Then, the magnitude Mw and the distance Rrup are examined as elements in a vector with an efficient scalar IM to evaluate whether they have any significant effect on the structural response. Subsequently, probabilistic seismic demand models (PSDMs) are developed using linear regression analyses based on a scalar IM and a vector-valued IM. Fragility curves are developed based on these PSDMs, and the influence of Mw and Rrup on the evaluation of the minimum required separation gap distance dg,min due to the pounding effect is examined. More than two hundred nonlinear time history analyses are performed based on the Cloud Analysis method. Seismic displacement demands that control of the global state of the structure, as well as the probability of structural pounding, are examined. The results of this research indicate that once Mw or Rrup is increased, fragility curves are shifted to greater values of IM, and the probability of the exceedance of a certain performance level is reduced. Also, the predictive power of Rrup seems to be greater than the one of Mw. On the other hand, it is revealed that Mw and Rrup induce variabilities in the demand solutions for adequate separation gap distance between the adjacent structures. Therefore, variation in Mw or Rrup may lead, in some cases, to unacceptable evaluations of the pounding effect in the capacity levels of structures.

The aim of this study is the probabilistic evaluation of the seismic performance of a multistory reinforced concrete (RC) frame structure due to the inter-story pounding effect. The assessment is performed through fragility curves at different performance levels. For this purpose, different probabilistic seismic demand models (PSDMs) are developed based on the real seismic response of the RC structure as a function of the spectral acceleration (Sa). In this direction, the inter-story (floor-tocolumn) pounding between an 8-story RC frame structure and a 3-story rigid barrier (very stiff structure) is examined. Three different initial gap distances (dg) between the adjacent structures are considered. The seismic fragility assessment of the 8-story RC structure without the inter-story pounding effect is also incorporated. Results indicate that the local performances of the columns of the 8-story RC structure are crucial demand parameters for the probabilistic assessment of the inter-story pounding risk. The fragility curves are shifted to lower values of Sa due to the pounding effect in comparison to the corresponding cases without pounding, while the probability of pounding between the examined structures is increased as the separation gap distance dg decreases. Nevertheless, the more exigent the performance level is the fragility curves move towards greater values of earthquake intensity.