Cytosine methylation is an epigenetic mark that promotes gene silencing and plays important roles in development and genome defense against transposons. Methylation patterns are established and maintained by DNA methyltransferases that catalyze transfer of a methyl group from S-adenosyl-L-methionine to cytosine bases in DNA. Erasure of cytosine methylation occurs during development, but the enzymatic basis of active demethylation remains controversial. In Arabidopsis thaliana, DEMETER (DME) activates the maternal expression of two imprinted genes silenced by methylation, and REPRESSOR OF SILENCING 1 (ROS1) is required for release of transcriptional silencing of a hypermethylated transgene. DME and ROS1 encode two closely related DNA glycosylase domain proteins, but it is unknown whether they participate directly in a DNA demethylation process or counteract silencing through an indirect effect on chromatin structure. Here we show that DME and ROS1 catalyze the release of 5-methylcytosine (5-meC) from DNA by a glycosylase͞lyase mechanism. Both enzymes also remove thymine, but not uracil, mismatched to guanine. DME and ROS1 show a preference for 5-meC over thymine in the symmetric dinucleotide CpG context, where most plant DNA methylation occurs. Nevertheless, they also have significant activity on both substrates at CpApG and asymmetric sequences, which are additional methylation targets in plant genomes. These findings suggest that a function of ROS1 and DME is to initiate erasure of 5-meC through a base excision repair process and provide strong biochemical evidence for the existence of an active DNA demethylation pathway in plants.Arabidopsis ͉ demethylation ͉ gene silencing ͉ methylation M ethylation of cytosine at carbon 5 of the pyrimidine ring [5-methylcytosine (5-meC)] is an epigenetic modification that guides formation of transcriptionally silent chromatin and allows transmission of specific patterns of gene activity across cellular divisions (1, 2). In eukaryotes, DNA methylation is detected in protists, fungi, plants, and animals (3) and plays important roles in the establishment of developmental programs (4, 5) and in genome defense against parasitic mobile elements (6). Most of mammalian and plant DNA methylation is restricted to symmetrical CpG sequences, but plants also have significant levels of cytosine methylation in the symmetric context CpNpG (where N is any nucleotide) and even in asymmetric contexts (2, 7). Similarly to other biochemical modifications such as protein phosphorylation and acetylation, DNA methylation is also reversible. Demethylation may take place as a passive process because of lack of maintenance methylation during several cycles of DNA replication or as an active mechanism in the absence of replication (8). In mammalian preimplantation embryos the maternal genome is demethylated by a passive process along cleavage stages, whereas the paternal genome is demethylated by an active mechanism immediately after fertilization (9). In addition to global demethylation, site-specific...

DNA cytosine methylation (5-meC) is a widespread epigenetic mark associated to gene silencing. In plants, DEMETER-LIKE (DML) proteins typified by Arabidopsis REPRESSOR OF SILENCING 1 (ROS1) initiate active DNA demethylation by catalyzing 5-meC excision. DML proteins belong to the HhH-GPD superfamily, the largest and most functionally diverse group of DNA glycosylases, but the molecular properties that underlie their capacity to specifically recognize and excise 5-meC are largely unknown. We have found that sequence similarity to HhH-GPD enzymes in DML proteins is actually distributed over two non-contiguous segments connected by a predicted disordered region. We used homology-based modeling to locate candidate residues important for ROS1 function in both segments, and tested our predictions by site-specific mutagenesis. We found that amino acids T606 and D611 are essential for ROS1 DNA glycosylase activity, whereas mutations in either of two aromatic residues (F589 and Y1028) reverse the characteristic ROS1 preference for 5-meC over T. We also found evidence suggesting that ROS1 uses Q607 to flip out 5-meC, while the contiguous N608 residue contributes to sequence-context specificity. In addition to providing novel insights into the molecular basis of 5-meC excision, our results reveal that ROS1 and its DML homologs possess a discontinuous catalytic domain that is unprecedented among known DNA glycosylases.

Arabidopsis ROS1 belongs to a family of plant 5-methycytosine DNA glycosylases that initiate DNA demethylation through base excision. ROS1 displays the remarkable capacity to excise 5-meC, and to a lesser extent T, while retaining the ability to discriminate effectively against C and U. We found that replacement of the C5-methyl group by halogen substituents greatly decreased excision of the target base. Furthermore, 5-meC was excised more efficiently from mismatches, whereas excision of T only occurred when mispaired with G. These results suggest that ROS1 specificity arises by a combination of selective recognition at the active site and thermodynamic stability of the target base. We also found that ROS1 is a low-turnover catalyst because it binds tightly to the abasic site left after 5-meC removal. This binding leads to a highly distributive behaviour of the enzyme on DNA substrates containing multiple 5-meC residues, and may help to avoid generation of double-strand breaks during processing of bimethylated CG dinucleotides. We conclude that the biochemical properties of ROS1 are consistent with its proposed role in protecting the plant genome from excess methylation.

DNA cytosine methylation is an epigenetic mark that promotes gene silencing and performs critical roles during reproduction and development in both plants and animals. The genomic distribution of DNA methylation is the dynamic outcome of opposing methylation and demethylation processes. In plants, active demethylation occurs through a base excision repair pathway initiated by 5-methycytosine (5-meC) DNA glycosylases of the REPRESSOR OF SILENCING 1 (ROS1)/ DEMETER (DME) family. To gain insight into the mechanism by which Arabidopsis ROS1 recognizes and excises 5-meC, we have identified those protein regions that are required for efficient DNA binding and catalysis. We have found that a short N-terminal lysine-rich domain conserved in members of the ROS1/DME family mediates strong methylation-independent binding of ROS1 to DNA and is required for efficient activity on 5-meC⅐G, but not for T⅐G processing. Removal of this domain does not significantly affect 5-meC excision from short molecules, but strongly decreases ROS1 activity on long DNA substrates. This region is not required for product binding and is not involved in the distributive behavior of the enzyme on substrates containing multiple 5-meC residues. Altogether, our results suggest that methylation-independent DNA binding allows ROS1 to perform a highly redundant search for efficient excision of a nondamaged, correctly paired base such as 5-meC in long stretches of DNA. These findings may have implications for understanding the evolution of structure and target specificity in DNA glycosylases.

Active DNA demethylation processes play a critical role in shaping methylation patterns, yet our understanding of the mechanisms involved is still fragmented and incomplete. REPRESSOR OF SILENCING 1 (ROS1) is a prototype member of a family of plant 5-methylcytosine DNA glycosylases that initiate active DNA demethylation through a base excision repair pathway. As ROS1 binds DNA non-specifically, we have critically tested the hypothesis that facilitated diffusion along DNA may contribute to target location by the enzyme. We have found that dissociation of ROS1 from DNA is severely restricted when access to both ends is obstructed by tetraloops obstacles. Unblocking any end facilitates protein dissociation, suggesting that random surface sliding is the main route to a specific target site. We also found that removal of the basic N-terminal domain of ROS1 significantly impairs the sliding capacity of the protein. Finally, we show that sliding increases the catalytic efficiency of ROS1 on 5-meC:G pairs, but not on T:G mispairs, thus suggesting that the enzyme achieves recognition and excision of its two substrate bases by different means. A model is proposed to explain how ROS1 finds its potential targets on DNA.