Neonicotinoids are highly potent and selective systemic insecticides, but their widespread use also has a growing impact on non-target animals and contaminates the environment, including surface waters. We tested the neonicotinoid insecticides commercially available in Hungary (acetamiprid, Mospilan; imidacloprid, Kohinor; thiamethoxam, Actara; clothianidin, Apacs; thiacloprid, Calypso) on cholinergic synapses that exist between the VD4 and RPeD1 neurons in the central nervous system of the pond snail Lymnaea stagnalis. In the concentration range used (0.01-1 mg/ml), neither chemical acted as an acetylcholine (ACh) agonist; instead, both displayed antagonist activity, inhibiting the cholinergic excitatory components of the VD4-RPeD1 connection. Thiacloprid (0.01 mg/ml) blocked almost 90 % of excitatory postsynaptic potentials (EPSPs), while the less effective thiamethoxam (0.1mg/ml) reduced the synaptic responses by about 15 %. The ACh-evoked membrane responses of the RPeD1 neuron were similarly inhibited by the neonicotinoids, confirming that the same ACh receptor (AChR) target was involved. We conclude that neonicotinoids act on nicotinergic acetylcholine receptors (nAChRs) in the snail CNS. This has been established previously in the insect CNS; however, our data indicate differences in the background mechanism or the nAChR binding site in the snail. Here we provide the first results concerning neonicotinoid-related toxic effects on the neuronal connections in the molluscan nervous system. Aquatic animals, including molluscs, are at direct risk while facing contaminated surface waters, and snails may provide a suitable model for further studies of the behavioural/neuronal consequences of intoxication by neonicotinoids.Tihany, Hungary, July 22, 2015
Dr. Mikko Nikinmaa Editorial Office Aquatic ToxicologyDear Dr Nikinmaa, Thank you very much for your response to our manuscript submission. We gratefully thank you and our reviewers for reading the manuscript, and we appreciate all the helpful comments made.After carefully checking the Reviewers' comments we improved the manuscript on the basis of their suggestions. Please find our detailed answers to the Reviewers below.
Reviewer #1:We greatly appreciate the Reviewer's comment "one of the best written manuscripts that I have reviewed"
Minor points
Materials and Methods
How was Lymnaea saline obtained? Is this the modified HiDi saline? If not, what is HiDi?For isolating the monosynaptic components of the synaptic responses between two neurons the perfusion chamber was filled with a modified saline which reduces the polysynaptically evoked postsynaptic responses and enhances the monosynaptic component (Berry and Pentreath, 1976). This modified saline contains higher amount of divalent cations (Ca 2+ and Mg 2+ ), therefore often nicknamed as HiDi saline (Brierly et al., 1997, Sivaramakrishnan et al., 2013. We added details to the text accordingly
Electrophysiological recordingThere is a Winlow 1991 anda Syed et al. 1990 (PNEC, EC50, mechanistic...) We...