Many pinniped populations precipitously declined during the 19th and 20th centuries due to overharvesting. In Uruguay, the South American sea lion (SASL) was harvested until 1986. Birth rates in two nearby breeding colonies have had opposite trends for at least 20 yr. We assessed different mechanisms that could explain opposite trends in birth rates in the two SASL colonies. We compared feeding habits (δ15N and δ13C) of breeding females, birth mass, individual growth rate and early survival of pups and the social structure between colonies. Breeding females from the two colonies did not differ in their feeding habits. However, male and female pups grew faster but had a lower survival in the second month in the smallest colony. We found differences in the social structures, with a higher proportion of males in the smallest colony. The latter is important because peripheral SASL males may abduct and kill pups, which may explain the lower survival of pups in smaller colonies. We believe that the cumulative effects of population extractions have lowered the local SASL population size and disrupted its social structure to the point where Allee‐like effects could become important and hamper the recovery of the Uruguayan SASL population.

In mammals, the transition from a terrestrial to an aquatic environment has implied a great number of adaptations. While in terrestrial mammals the presentation of the foetus at birth is typically cephalic, in strictly aquatic mammals as cetaceans and sirenians the presentation of the foetus is mainly breech. The order Pinnipedia is the most recently evolved group of marine mammals and has an amphibian lifestyle. We document, for the first time, the parturition process in the largest breeding colony of the South American fur seal Arctocephalus australis in Uruguay and compare our results with the scarce information available for other species. The analysis of the parturition processes shows that the cephalic/breech birth ratio was 1. In this species, the presentation of the foetus did not affect the total duration of the parturition process, but the cephalic presentation implied a significantly lower duration of the stage 1 of birth, a trend that is also observed in other Otariid species. Phylogenetic reconstructions suggest that O. flavescens and E. jubatus are older than the Arctocephalus genus, having their most recent common ancestor dated between 5-5.8 mybp. Within the Arctocephalus genus, A. australis would be the most recent species (0.7 mybp). In this light, the skewed ratios of breech presentation in older otariids species may suggest a convergent adaptation toward the aquatic life. We hope this finding will promote an increase of studies aiming for a more detailed examination on the adaptive processes involved in the selection of both types of fetal presentations, and their potential effect on the survival of the pup.