For the past decade, cardiac safety screening to evaluate the propensity of drugs to produce QT interval prolongation and Torsades de Pointes (TdP) arrhythmia has been conducted according to ICH S7B and ICH E14 guidelines. Central to the existing approach are hERG channel assays and in vivo QT measurements. Although effective, the present paradigm carries a risk of unnecessary compound attrition and high cost, especially when considering costly thorough QT (TQT) studies conducted later in drug development. The Comprehensive In Vitro Proarrhythmia Assay (CiPA) initiative is a publicprivate collaboration with the aim of updating the existing cardiac safety testing paradigm to better evaluate arrhythmia risk and remove the need for TQT studies. It is hoped that CiPA will produce a standardized ion channel assay approach, incorporating defined tests against major cardiac ion channels, the results of which then inform evaluation of proarrhythmic actions in silico, using human ventricular action potential reconstructions. Results are then to be confirmed using human (stem cell-derived) cardiomyocytes. This perspective article reviews the rationale, progress of, and challenges for the CiPA initiative, if this new paradigm is to replace existing practice and, in time, lead to improved and widely accepted cardiac safety testing guidelines.

The main finding of this work is that providing a relatively low cell concentration is used in IonWorks HT, the potency information generated correlates well with that determined using conventional electrophysiology. The effect on potency of increasing cell concentration may relate to a reduced free concentration of test compound owing to partitioning into cell membranes. In summary, the IonWorks HT hERG assay can generate pIC50 values based on a direct assessment of channel function in a timeframe short enough to influence chemical design.

Owing to its association with Torsades de Pointes, drug-induced QT interval prolongation has been and remains a significant hurdle to the development of safe, effective medicines. Genetic and pharmacological evidence highlighting the pivotal role the human ether-a-go-go-related gene (hERG) channel was a critical step in understanding how to start addressing this issue. It led to the development of hERG assays with the rapid throughput needed for the short timescales required in early drug discovery. The resulting volume of hERG data has fostered in silico models to help chemists design compounds with reduced hERG potency. In early drug discovery, a pragmatic approach based on exceeding a given potency value has been required to decide when a compound is likely to carry a low QT risk, to support its progression to late-stage discovery. At this point, the in vivo efficacy and metabolism characteristics of the potential drug are generally defined, as well its safety profile, which includes usually a dog study to assess QT interval prolongation risk. The hERG and in vivo QT data, combined with the likely indication and the estimated free drug level for efficacy, are put together to assess the risk that the potential drug will prolong QT in man. Further data may be required to refine the risk assessment before making the major investment decisions for full development. The non-clinical data are essential to inform decisions about compound progression and to optimize the design of clinical QT studies. Redfern et al., 2003). Given the cost of bringing a new drug to the market [estimated in the year 2000 at approximately US$800m (DiMasi et al., 2003)], the proportion of drugs withdrawn owing to QT prolongation/TdP was a significant concern for pharmaceutical companies. The headline drugs withdrawn from sale were just the tip of the iceberg, however, as the development of many more potential drugs was halted following evidence of a QT prolongation risk and some drugs remain on sale despite carrying a QT risk but cannot be prescribed to certain patient groups. Such was the level of concern in the pharmaceutical industry that the 'QT issue' was jokingly dubbed 'Pharmageddon' (WS Redfern, pers. comm.). All in all this was, and remains, a significant hurdle to the development of effective but safe medicines in an industry needing to focus on improving its productivity by reducing safety-related attrition. This overview aims to introduce the topic and summarize non-clinical strategies to assess and reduce QT interval prolongation risk. It builds on a previous review of the topic and complements more specific case studies described by Valentin et al. (2010) and is considered from a broader perspective in the commentary by Guth and Rast (2010). British Journal of Pharmacology

IntroductionDetection of drug-induced pro-arrhythmic risk is a primary concern for pharmaceutical companies and regulators. Increased risk is linked to prolongation of the QT interval on the body surface ECG. Recent studies have shown that multiple ion channel interactions can be required to predict changes in ventricular repolarisation and therefore QT intervals. In this study we attempt to predict the result of the human clinical Thorough QT (TQT) study, using multiple ion channel screening which is available early in drug development.MethodsIon current reduction was measured, in the presence of marketed drugs which have had a TQT study, for channels encoded by hERG, CaV1.2, NaV1.5, KCNQ1/MinK, and Kv4.3/KChIP2.2. The screen was performed on two platforms — IonWorks Quattro (all 5 channels, 34 compounds), and IonWorks Barracuda (hERG & CaV1.2, 26 compounds). Concentration–effect curves were fitted to the resulting data, and used to calculate a percentage reduction in each current at a given concentration.Action potential simulations were then performed using the ten Tusscher and Panfilov (2006), Grandi et al. (2010) and O'Hara et al. (2011) human ventricular action potential models, pacing at 1 Hz and running to steady state, for a range of concentrations.ResultsWe compared simulated action potential duration predictions with the QT prolongation observed in the TQT studies. At the estimated concentrations, simulations tended to underestimate any observed QT prolongation. When considering a wider range of concentrations, and conventional patch clamp rather than screening data for hERG, prolongation of ≥ 5 ms was predicted with up to 79% sensitivity and 100% specificity.DiscussionThis study provides a proof-of-principle for the prediction of human TQT study results using data available early in drug development. We highlight a number of areas that need refinement to improve the method's predictive power, but the results suggest that such approaches will provide a useful tool in cardiac safety assessment.

Drug toxicity to T-antigen-immortalized human liver epithelial (THLE) cells stably transfected with plasmid vectors that encoded human cytochrome P450s 1A2, 2C9, 2C19, 2D6, or 3A4, or an empty plasmid vector (THLE-Null), was investigated. An automated screening platform, which included 1% dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO) vehicle, 2.7% bovine serum in the culture medium, and assessed 3-(4,5-dimethylthiazol-2-yl)-5-(3-carboxymethoxyphenyl)-2-(4-sulfophenyl)-2H-tetrazolium reduction, was used to evaluate the cytotoxicity of 103 drugs after 24h. Twenty-two drugs caused cytotoxicity to THLE-Null cells, with EC₅₀ ≤ 200 μM; 21 of these drugs (95%) have been reported to cause human liver injury. Eleven drugs exhibited lower EC₅₀ values in cells transfected with CYP3A4 (THLE-3A4 cells) than in THLE-Null cells; 10 of these drugs (91%) caused human liver injury. An additional 8 drugs, all of which caused human liver injury, exhibited potentiated THLE-3A4 cell toxicity when evaluated using a manual protocol that included 0.2% or 1% DMSO, but not bovine serum. Fourteen of the drugs that exhibited potentiated THLE-3A4 cell toxicity are known to be metabolized by P450s to reactive intermediates. These drugs included troglitazone, which was shown to undergo metabolic bioactivation and covalent binding to proteins in THLE-3A4 cells. A single drug (rimonabant) exhibited marked THLE cell toxicity but did not cause human liver injury; this drug had very low reported plasma exposure. These results indicate that evaluation of toxicity to THLE-Null and THLE-3A4 cell lines during drug discovery may aid selection of drugs with reduced propensity to cause drug-induced liver injury and that consideration of human exposure is required to enhance data interpretation.