In many social species physical attributes correlate with dominance rankings and influence the outcomes of dyadic interactions. We investigated the processes which affect white rhinoceros social behaviour in response to a reduction in horn size asymmetries within a group of subadult individuals. We monitored agonistic social interactions and the orderliness of social rankings between six free ranging rhinoceroses before and after they underwent a second dehorning procedure. We used a modified version of Landau's h to measure linearity, a score of steepness to measure power asymmetry, and a measure of triangle transitivity to assess relationships in the presence of null dyads. Agonistic social interactions were significantly greater after the monitored dehorning procedure. Hierarchies possessed significant steepness and transitivity prior to the procedure but not after. Linearity was nonsignificant and rank order did not correspond to changes in horn size or age. Our results provide the first evidence of a dominance hierarchy among free-ranging white rhinoceroses outside of reproductive competition but indicate that physical attributes alone do not explain social rankings. Rhinoceroses transitioned to a more egalitarian dominance structure than a despotic one after the procedure, but dominance ranks were only weakly differentiated within the group. Although a reduction in horn asymmetries may increase agonistic behaviours through psychosocial or behavioural changes, drier climatic conditions cannot be ruled out as the causative factor and as the subadult group stayed together rather than dispersing, any increased fitness costs are likely to be minimal and outweighed by the benefits of group membership.