Studies in the United States and Europe have investigated the relationship of the Five- Factor Model of personality to effectiveness for domestic managers. This article reports on the relationship of the Five-Factor Model of personality to job performance for a group of Middle Eastern expatriate managers. Job performance ratings from the expatriate’s host- and home-country bosses indicate that agreeableness and conscientiousness were related to home-country ratings of job performance, but not host-country ratings.
In rapidly growing Asian economies, the need to recruit and train additional leadership talent is particularly problematic, as the demand for talent continues to outstrip available indigenous human capital. Yet most leadership development research to date has focused on US samples. The current study extends our knowledge about how managers develop as leaders by analyzing and comparing qualitative data on key developmental events and lessons from senior executives in China and India, and including a comparison to similar recent US data.
We support McCall's (2010) thesis but use a cultural lens to focus on the limitations of his arguments from three perspectives. First, we agree that experience is beneficial but have to disagree with his assertion that ''there really is no need to do more research'' on how ''certain experiences matter more than others.'' Second, we endorse McCall's acknowledgement that ''it is the framework for understanding the lessons of those experiences, however, that has the most potential for helping people think through their own development.'' But we caution that cross-national studies introduce additional leadership lessons to be learned-possibly not just by managers in the country or region where the study was implemented but by business leaders in other parts of the world. Lastly, McCall suggests that the key return on experience is in ''the long-term impact of higher quality leadership talent on organizational performance.'' But in our view, he stops short of providing feasible options for translating experiences into higher quality leadership. So we propose an alternate way of embedding the transfer of leadership learning within the culture of organizations.Two assumptions guide our commentary: (a) Given the reality of today's expanding global business activity, the experiences
scite is a Brooklyn-based organization that helps researchers better discover and understand research articles through Smart Citations–citations that display the context of the citation and describe whether the article provides supporting or contrasting evidence. scite is used by students and researchers from around the world and is funded in part by the National Science Foundation and the National Institute on Drug Abuse of the National Institutes of Health.