Goran Wall's "Exergy, Ecology and Democracy - Concepts of a vital society or
a proposal for an exergy tax" has come a long way since its presentation in
1992. Wall has extended the thermodynamics to the sustainability analysis of
economic, environmental and societal models. The authors of this paper aim
to discuss Wall's intuitions in today's scenario. Governments are assuming
increasing measures against climate change and toward sustainability.
However, these measures do not affect the concentration of greenhouse gases
and global heating. It is an evident failure from a thermodynamic point of
view. The economic indicators used by governments to measure the progress
toward U.N. Sustainability Development Goals and the Paris Agreement reveal
a scarce consistency. One of the most used is "domestic material
consumption" (DMC). It accounts for the mass balance of the materials
entering or exiting a national economic system. However, it lacks
consistency and delivers insufficient information because it neglects the
impacts of import-export. As Wall shows, more effective and consistent
indicators are necessary to account for sustainability. The most relevant is
exergy, which has been presented and discussed widely.
Thirty years ago, Goran Wall published ?Exergy Ecology Democracy - Concepts
of a vital society or a proposal for an exergy tax?. This paper discusses
this milestone contribution by Wall. It has traced a path toward economic,
environmental and societal sustainability and proposed exergy as a robust
indicator for measuring progress. This paper is divided into two parts. The
first focuses on better understanding Wall?s role in today?s scenario. This
second part presents different methods that allow using exergy to assess the
sustainability of economic, industrial and societal processes. First, it
presents an example showing the inadequacy of domestic material consumption
(DMC) in evaluating the sustainability of import-export operations. Second,
how exergy can apply to increase the significance of DMC has been discussed.
A new indicator that allows coupling with DMC has been defined to improve
the information delivered by DMC and make it a more effective sustainability
indicator. Third, some ecological indicators are discussed. The use of
exergy to integrate DMC and assess lifecycle and polluting emissions into
the environment has been discussed. Finally, an effective exergy tax
proposal is presented as an instrument for stimulating an effective
transition toward sustainability of consumption and people?s habits.
scite is a Brooklyn-based organization that helps researchers better discover and understand research articles through Smart Citations–citations that display the context of the citation and describe whether the article provides supporting or contrasting evidence. scite is used by students and researchers from around the world and is funded in part by the National Science Foundation and the National Institute on Drug Abuse of the National Institutes of Health.