During meiosis a large subset of interhomolog recombination repair intermediates form within the physical context of the synaptonemal complex (SC), a protein-rich structure assembled at the interface of aligned homologous chromosomes. However, the functional relationship between SC structure and homologous recombination remains poorly defined. In prior work we determined that tripartite SC is dispensable for recombination in S. cerevisiae; SC central element proteins Ecm11 and Gmc2 instead limit the number of recombination events. Here we report that while dispensable for recombination per se, SC central element proteins influence the processing of interhomolog recombination intermediates in a manner that minimizes errors in mismatch correction. Failure to correct mis-paired bases within heteroduplex at meiotic recombination sites leads to genotypically sectored colonies (post meiotic segregation events) arising from mitotic proliferation of mismatch-containing spores. We discovered an increase in post-meiotic segregation at the THR1 locus in cells lacking Ecm11 or Gmc2, or in the SC-deficient but crossover recombination-proficient zip1[Δ21-163] mutant. High-throughput sequencing of octad meiotic products revealed a genome-wide increase in recombination events with uncorrected mismatches in ecm11 mutants relative to wild type. Meiotic cells missing Ecm11 also display longer gene conversion tracts, but tract length alone does not account for the higher frequency of uncorrected mismatches. Interestingly, the per-nucleotide mismatch frequency is elevated in ecm11 mutants when analyzing all gene conversion tracts, but is similar between wild type and ecm11 if one considers only those events with uncorrected mismatches. Our data suggest that a subset of recombination events is similarly susceptible to mismatch repair errors in both wild type and ecm11 strains, but in ecm11 mutants many more recombination events fall into this inefficient repair category. Finally, we observe elevated post-meiotic segregation at THR1 in mutants with a dual deficiency in MutSγ-mediated crossover recombination and SC assembly, but not in the mlh3 mutant, which lacks MutSγ crossovers but has abundant SC. We propose that SC structure promotes efficient mismatch repair of joint molecule recombination intermediates resolved via both MutSγ-associated and MutSγ-independent pathways, and is the molecular basis for elevated post-meiotic segregation in both MutSγ crossover-proficient (ecm11, gmc2) and MutSγ crossover-deficient (msh4, zip3) strains.