Multiple studies have focused on the importance of single modalities (visual, auditory, olfactory) in eliciting anti-predator behavior, however multiple channels are often engaged simultaneously. While examining responses to multiple cues can potentially reveal more complex behavioral responses, little is known about how multimodal processing evolves. By contrasting response to familiar and novel predators, insights can be gained into the evolution of multimodal responses. We studied brown anoles’ (Anolis sagrei) response to acoustic and visual predatory cues of a common potential predator, the great-tailed grackle Quiscalus mexicanus and to the American kestrel Falco sparverius, a species found in other populations but not present in our study population. We observed anole behavior before and after a stimulus and quantified rates of looking, display, and locomotion. Anoles increased their rate of locomotion in response to grackle models, an effect modulated by grackle vocalizations. No such response or modulation was seen when anoles were presented with kestrel stimuli. This suggests that the degree of sophistication of anole response to predators is experience dependent and that relaxed selection can result in reduced anti-predator response following loss of predators.

Cyanobacteria, an increasingly important epiphyte on macroalgae and seagrass, have been shown to have strong effects on its hosts; this association has been identified as a driving mechanism that maintains algal blooms on coral reefs. We examined both the costs and benefits of epiphytism on 2 algal congeners of Halimeda (H. tuna and H. opuntia), both of which are abundant members of tropical reef communities in the Caribbean. To evaluate potential benefits of an associational defense as well as costs to growth, we manipulated herbivore access to (uncaged/caged) and cyanobacteria presence on (epiphytized/cleaned) 2 species of Halimeda on shallow patch reefs in Belize and measured change in branch length and segment number after 10 (H. tuna) and 5 (H. opuntia) days. Cyanobacterial epiphytes did not serve as an associational defense from herbivory as there were no differences between caged and uncaged treatments for either response variable. The presence of cyanobacterial epiphytes did not affect the growth of branches or net generation of new segments, demonstrating there was also no cost to growth. The robustness of both species of Halimeda to epiphytism contrasts strongly with recent research that found strong effects of epiphytes on several other species of tropical algae. Our results may be attributed to the unique characteristics of Halimeda, a heavily physically and chemically defended algal genus, and the shallow nature of the patch reefs reducing the potential for significant light limitation. These findings suggest that close interactions such as epiphytism may not be as generalizable as originally assumed; studies must consider differences among host species, as this may lead to a better understanding of community-wide effects.