A recent article in the journal Cortex (Chalkia et al. 2020) has claimed a failure to verify the results reported in our 2010 study describing the phenomenon of reconsolidation updating using the retrieval-extinction protocol (Schiller et al., 2010). Since the journal did not grant us the right of reply, we publish our response here. We show, among other things, that a reanalysis of the raw data reproduces the results and contend that the conclusions are valid.