The bulky ligands L(X)- (L(X) = (2,6-C6H3X2)NC(Me)CHC(Me)N(2,6-C6H3X2), X =Cl, Me) can be used to generate fluxional mononuclear arene complexes [L(X)Rh(eta4-arene)] (arene = benzene, toluene, m-xylene, mesitylene), which for X = Me disproportionate to fluxional dinuclear complexes [[L(Me)Rh]2(anti-mu-arene)]. For both mononuclear and dinuclear complexes, steric interactions do not stop the fluxionality but govern the preferred orientation of the methyl-substituted arenes, thus allowing indirect determination of the static NMR parameters. For the mu-arene complexes, two distinct types of fluxionality are proposed on the basis of calculations: ring rotation and metal shift. In the solid state, the toluene complex has an eta4(1,2,3,4):eta4(3,4,5,6)-bridged structure; the NMR analysis indicates that the benzene and m-xylene complexes have similar structures. The mesitylene complex, however, has an unprecedented eta3(1,2,3):eta3(3,4,5)-bridged structure, which is proposed to correspond to the transition state for arene rotation in the other cases. Steric factors are thought to be responsible for this reversal of stabilities.