One of the challenges of utilizing advanced high-strength steels is their limited ability to withstand the forming of cut edges. Large production quantities of parts often lead to mechanical punching/shearing processes in blank preparation, providing a challenging starting point for forming processes. The most commonly used edge ductility test is the ISO 16630 hole-expansion test to describe stretch-flangeability properties. However, this method has been widely criticized for its large-scatter, unreliable results and the fact that it covers only a certain stress-strain state of cut edge forming. In addition, it does not provide enough data to be reliably used in forming simulations to predict edge failures. This paper presents an approach to create a more comprehensive way of describing overall edge ductility. Multiple edge forming test methods coupled with digital image correlation (DIC) were selected in order to investigate different edge loading scenarios in both open and closed trim line forming situations. Data regarding limiting local strain before cracking was collected for several steel grades, and results are gathered in 2D and 3D “Edge FLC”-figures. Attempts to utilize these results for simulation purposes are also presented. Results indicate that this approach can be useful to evaluate overall edge forming limits.

Abstract. The effects of microstructure on the cutting and hole expansion properties of three thermomechanically rolled steels have been investigated. The yield strength of the studied 3 mm thick strip steels was approximately 700 MPa. Detailed microstructural studies using laser scanning confocal microscopy (LCSM), FESEM and FESEM-EBSD revealed that the three investigated materials consist of 1) single-phase polygonal ferrite, 2) polygonal ferrite with precipitates and 3) granular bainite. The quality of mechanically sheared edges were evaluated using visual inspection and LSCM, while hole expansion properties were characterised according to the methods described in ISO 16630. Roughness values (R a and R z ) of the sheet edge with different cutting clearances varied between 12 μm to 21 μm and 133 μm to 225 μm, respectively. Mean hole expansion ratios varied from 28.4% to 40.5%. It was shown that granular bainite produced the finest cutting edge, but the hole expansion ratio remained at the same level as in the steel comprising single-phase ferrite. This indicates that a single-phase ferritic matrix enhances hole expansion properties even with low quality edges. A brief discussion of the microstructural features controlling the cutting quality and hole expansion properties is given.

One limitation of the standardized ISO 16630 hole expansion test is that it provides only one result: limiting hole expansion ratio (HER). In practice, steels with similar HER values can have different cut edge forming behavior due to possible differences in strain localization tendencies. Digital image correlation (DIC) strain measurement during formability testing allows more in-detail analysis of strain-state near the cut edge. In this paper, strain evolution during hole expansion testing was investigated for three 800 MPa tensile strength grade hot-rolled strip steels. The steels were selected to have differences in microstructures and anisotropies of mechanical properties. Two different hole expansion test methods with DIC strain measurement were utilized to investigate different edge loading scenarios: in-plane stretching with a flat-top punch and more out-of-plane stretching with a hemispherical punch. Test holes were prepared according to ISO 16630 standard. In order to examine strain evolution and localization during testing, strains were measured with circle-shape sections around the hole in various distances from the cut edge. Strain localization behavior was investigated in different sheet directions and the effect on the hole expansion ratio was evaluated. Results show considerable differences in the cut edge forming behavior between the investigated materials.