We measured the density of vibrational states (DOS) and the specific heat of various glassy and crystalline polymorphs of SiO 2 . The typical (ambient) glass shows a well-known excess of specific heat relative to the typical crystal (α-quartz). This, however, holds when comparing a lower-density glass to a higherdensity crystal. For glassy and crystalline polymorphs with matched densities, the DOS of the glass appears as the smoothed counterpart of the DOS of the corresponding crystal; it reveals the same number of the excess states relative to the Debye model, the same number of all states in the low-energy region, and it provides the same specific heat. This shows that glasses have higher specific heat than crystals not due to disorder, but because the typical glass has lower density than the typical crystal. DOI: 10.1103/PhysRevLett.112.025502 PACS numbers: 63.20.-e, 07.85.-m, 76.80.+y The low-temperature thermodynamic properties of glasses are accepted to be anomalously different from those of crystals due to the inherent disorder of the glass structure. At temperatures of ∼10 K, the specific heat of glasses shows an excess relativetothatofthecorrespondingcrystals.Theexcessspecific heat is related to a distinct feature in the spectrum of the atomic vibrations: At frequencies of ∼1 THz, glasses exhibit an excess of states above the Debye level of the acoustic waves, the socalled "boson peak." The excess of specific heat and the boson peak are universally observed for all glasses and by all relevant experimental techniques. However, the results still do not converge to a unified answer to how disorder causes these anomalies.Themajorityofthemodelsexplainthebosonpeakbyappealing tovarious glass-specific features. Theseincludelow-energy optical modes [1], onset of mechanical instability related to saddle points in the energy landscape [2] or to jamming [3][4][5], local vibrationalmodes of clusters [6] or locally favoured structures [7], librations [8] or other coherent motions [9] of molecular fragments, crossover of local and acoustic modes [10], quasilocal vibrations of atoms in an anharmonic potential [11], broadening of vibrational states in the Ioffe-Regel crossover regime [12], spatial variation of the elastic moduli [13], breakdown of the continuum approximation [14,15], and topologically diverse defects [16], to cite the most important ones.Alternatively, the boson peak is identified as the counterpart of the acoustic van Hove singularities of crystals, i.e., explained by the piling up of the vibrational states of the acousticlike branches near the boundary of the pseudoBrillouin zone [17][18][19][20].Diverging in explanations of the boson peak, all models agree that the excess states and the excess specific heat of
