We examined the breeding success of common loons (Gavia immer) and made observations of loons feeding their young on small lakes (5.3–75 ha) with different alkalinities (−73 to 1804 μequiv./L) near Sudbury, Ontario. Alkalinity, pH, and conductivity were highly correlated with each other. There was a significant positive relationship between successful breeding and alkalinity on 68 lakes surveyed in 1982. Discriminant analysis showed that alkalinity, area, and colour of the lake contributed significantly to discrimination among lakes with successful, unsuccessful, and no breeding attempts. Lack of a breeding attempt tended to be associated with small, brown, low-alkalinity lakes, and successful breeding with large, clear, high-alkalinity lakes. For lakes with breeding attempts in 1982–1984, alkalinity (all years), depth (1983), and area (1984) provided significant discrimination between unsuccessful lakes and those on which young were raised. Unsuccessful breeding resulted primarily from brood mortalities on acidic lakes. Adult loons were more successful at securing fish on high-alkalinity lakes than on low-alkalinity lakes, and this may reflect differences in fish densities. A pair of loons attempting to raise a chick on a fishless, acidic lake fed the chick benthic algae and possibly benthic invertebrates, but flew to other lakes to feed themselves. We suggest that the high level of brood mortalities on acidic lakes resulted from a shortage of suitable food for the young.

Amphibians were present in 118 potential breeding sites 9–66 km northeast and southwest of Sudbury, Ontario. Detailed chemical analyses were done for 38 ponds, and 23 variables were subjected to principal components analysis to summarize the main gradients in pond chemistry. Discriminant analysis using scores of the first three principal components showed that the presence of Rana pipiens, R. clamitans and Hyla crucifer was positively related to buffering status (alkalinity, pH, and other correlated variables); the presence of H. crucifer was also negatively related to atmospheric deposition status (cadmium, nickel, other correlated metals, and sulphate). Discriminant analysis using the original water chemistry variables confirms these general patterns. Two species show relationships with buffering status variables: Rana sylvatica with conductivity and R. clamitans with alkalinity. Three species also show negative correlation with metal levels in pond water: Bufo americanus with nickel, R. clamitans with aluminum, and R. pipiens with zinc. Although most of the species expected do occur in the Sudbury area, the distributions of several species appear related to buffering status and metals present in their immediate environemnt. There were only two observations of Ambystoma maculatum, and low numbers of egg masses were noted for R. sylvatica.

Alvo, Robert. 2009. Common Loon, Gavia immer, breeding success in relation to lake pH and lake size over 25 years.Canadian Field-Naturalist 123(2): 146-156.I monitored Common Loon (Gavia immer) breeding success in relation to lake pH (range 4.0-8.5) between 1982 and 2007 on 38 single-pair lakes (5-88 ha) in the Sudbury, Ontario, area. No chicks fledged on lakes with pH < 4.4. Chicks fledged on lakes with slightly higher pH only if the lakes were relatively large. Acidic lakes became less acidic as sulphur dioxide emissions from the Sudbury smelters and sulphur deposition from other long-range sources decreased. Two lakes initially too acidic to support successful loon reproduction eventually had successful reproduction. One loon pair used two large acidic lakes (combined area 140 ha) connected by shallow rapids, and one of the adults made extremely long dives (χ -= 99 s) while foraging for the chicks. One chick died on that lake after apparently ingesting a very large food item; the lack of smaller items was attributed to the lake's acidity. My results suggest that a shortage of food for chicks is the main reason why low pH reduces breeding success. I suggest that, for lakes without high levels of dissolved organic carbon (DOC), the critical pH for loon breeding success is approximately 4.3, and the suboptimal pH is approximately 4.4-6.0.

No abstract

No abstract