The distribution behavior of a drug within a cell is an important, yet often overlooked, variable in both activity and differential selectivity. In normal cells, drugs with weakly basic properties are known to be extensively compartmentalized in acidic organelles such as lysosomes via ion trapping. Several cancer cell lines have been shown to have defective acidification of endocytic organelles and therefore have a diminished capacity to sequester such lysosomotropic agents. In this study, we tested the hypothesis that the low lysosomal pH of normal cells plays an important role in protecting normal tissues from the toxic effects of lysosomotropic anticancer drugs. The influence of lysosomal pH status on the toxicity of inhibitors of the molecular chaperone Hsp90 that did or did not possess lysosomotropic properties was evaluated in mice. Toxicity of Hsp90 inhibitors was evaluated in normal mice and in mice treated with chloroquine to elevate lysosomal pH by assessing morbidity and utilizing biochemical assays to diagnose hepatic and renal toxicity. Toxicity of the lysosomotropic inhibitor 17-dimethylaminoethylamino-17-demethoxy-geldanamycin (17-DMAG) was significantly enhanced in mice with elevated lysosomal pH relative to mice with normal lysosomal pH. In contrast, elevation of lysosomal pH had no significant impact on toxicity of the nonlysosomotropic inhibitor geldanamycin. These results support the notion that the low lysosomal pH of normal cells plays an important role in protecting these cells from the toxic effects of anticancer agents with lysosomotropic properties and has implications for the design/selection of anticancer drugs with improved safety and differential selectivity.

Drug distribution in cells is a fundamentally important, yet often overlooked, variable in drug efficacy. Many weakly basic anticancer agents accumulate extensively in the acidic lysosomes of normal cells through ion trapping. Lysosomal trapping reduces the activity of anticancer drugs, since anticancer drug targets are often localized in the cell cytosol or nucleus. Some cancer cells have defective acidification of lysosomes, which causes a redistribution of trapped drugs from the lysosomes to the cytosol. We have previously established that such differences in drug localization between normal and cancer cells can contribute to the apparent selectivity of weakly basic drugs to cancer cells in vitro. In this work, we tested whether this intracellular distribution-based drug selectivity could be optimized based on the acid dissociation constant (pKa) of the drug, which is one of the determinants of lysosomal sequestration capacity. We synthesized seven weakly basic structural analogs of the Hsp90 inhibitor geldanamycin (GDA) with pKa values ranging from 5 to 12. The selectivity of each analog was expressed by taking ratios of anti-proliferative IC50 values of the inhibitors in normal fibroblasts to the IC50 values in human leukemic HL-60 cells. Similar selectivity assessments were performed in a pair of cancer cell lines that differed in lysosomal pH as a result of siRNA-mediated alteration of vacuolar proton ATPase subunit expression. Optimal selectivity was observed for analogs with pKa values near 8. Similar trends were observed with commercial anticancer agents with varying weakly basic pKa values. These evaluations advance our understanding of how weakly basic properties can be optimized to achieve maximum anticancer drug selectivity towards cancer cells with defective lysosomal acidification in vitro. Additional in vivo studies are needed to examine the utility of this approach for enhancing selectivity.