For protected species under management, ensuring that genetic and phenotypic diversity is maintained above critical levels is one of the primary goals of conservation (Funk, McKay, Hohenlohe, &

In this investigation a single genetic stock of Hood River, Oregon, Chinook Salmon Oncorhynchus tshawytscha was reared at three different hatchery facilities over three brood years (2008–2010) and monitored for size, growth rate, gill Na+,K+‐ATPase activity, condition factor, whole body energetics, and precocious male maturation (age‐2 minijack rate). This experimental design provided a unique opportunity to isolate environmental from genetic effects on salmonid life history. Differences in the seasonal thermal regimes and associated growth profiles among the three facilities resulted in modest differences in smolt development but significant variation in size at release (range = 18 g body weight, 118 mm FL to 31 g body weight, 142 mm FL) and minijack rates (range = 4.8–57.1%) among groups. Previous studies have found a positive relationship between body size at release and minijack rates. However, in this investigation the release group with the largest mean body size consistently had the lowest minijack rates. This unique result may be due to the more natural thermal regime and feeding profile experienced by fish at this facility compared with that of the other two facilities and highlights the importance and potential benefits of adhering to a more “wildlike” growth profile in hatchery supplementation programs. Received February 24, 2014; accepted May 29, 2014

The aim of this study was to assess the effect of differing hatchery rearing environments on smolting, early male maturation, and smolt-to-adult return rates (SARs) in Chinook Salmon Oncorhynchus tshawytscha. In this investigation, SARs were compared for spring Chinook Salmon from Hood River stock reared at three different hatcheries and then released into the Hood River, replicated over three separate years (2010)(2011)(2012). Differences in SARs were found both between rearing groups and release years. Smolts reared at Pelton Ladder had consistently higher SARs than those reared at either Parkdale or Carson hatcheries. Smolt length at release was positively correlated to SARs across years and rearing groups. In addition, multiple regression models suggested that attributes related to smolt quality were positively related to SARs while the minijack rate was negatively related to SAR. Migration of smolts downstream after release was also assessed. Larger smolts were faster downstream migrants and migration rate was positively related to subsequent SAR. Differences in smolt quality and SAR between rearing groups is attributed to differing patterns of growth in the different hatchery environments. The best-performing smolts came from rearing groups that experienced a strong seasonal change in growth rate: relatively high growth in the summer, reduced growth and depletion of energetic stores in the autumn and winter, and then increased growth again in the spring. This pattern of seasonal anabolic and catabolic changes has been termed the wild fish template, and generating this physiological pattern generally may be applicable to hatchery-reared Chinook Salmon.

Hatchery spring Chinook Salmon Oncorhynchus tshawytscha from Parkdale Hatchery on the Hood River, Oregon, and Carson National Fish Hatchery (CNFH) on the Wind River, Washington, were reared under a common‐garden experimental regime at CNFH over three consecutive brood years (2008–2010) to assess the effects of stock on smoltification and early male maturation. Rearing groups were monitored for size, percent solid (a surrogate for whole‐body lipid), gill Na+,K+‐ATPase activity, and rate of precocious maturation in males (i.e., age‐2 minijack rate). Despite rearing of the stocks under identical conditions, the out‐of‐basin Hood River stock was significantly smaller throughout the study and at release as smolts, had lower whole‐body lipid at release, and had lower gill Na+,K+‐ATPase activity at release than the Carson stock; furthermore, the Hood River stock exhibited much higher mean minijack rates than the Carson stock (45% versus 23% of males). Using logistic regression, we demonstrated that the threshold size for initiation of early male maturation was significantly lower for the Hood River stock than for the Carson stock, suggesting a genetic basis for this life history difference. The present study highlights the importance of understanding how specific genotypes may respond differently to the unique environmental conditions in a given hatchery environment. These differences may in turn influence physiological and life history pathways that affect smolt‐to‐adult return rates and the demography of returning adults.

For over 150-years, hatchery-origin anadromous salmon and trout have been reared and released throughout the Pacific Northwest to mitigate for lost habitat and sustain harvest opportunity. Some studies demonstrate that introgression of hatchery and naturally produced fish may constrain conservation efforts through maladaptive genetic processes. However, empirical demonstrations of the influence of these genetic interactions on population productivity are lacking, making it difficult to assess their importance relative to other drivers of productivity. We estimated the effect of the proportion of hatchery-origin spawners (pHOS), proportionate natural influence (PNI), and hatchery fish releases on natural adult winter steelhead recruitment in the Hood River, Oregon over a 27-year period of record. Adult winter steelhead productivity was not associated with pHOS and PNI. However, natural winter steelhead productivity was positively associated with ocean conditions, stream flow, and hatchery fish release numbers, while negatively associated with pinniped abundance. Our analysis highlights the importance of quantifying the influence of hatchery programs on fish production relative to environmental factors known to affect natural-origin anadromous fish recruitment.