Three methods of evaluating vesicle mean radii and polydispersity, quasi-elastic light scattering (QLS), freeze-fracture electron microscopy (FF-TEM), and cryo-transmission electron microscopy (cryo-TEM), were used to determine the size distributions of spontaneous vesicles made from mixtures of cetyltrimethylammonium tosylate (CTAT) and sodium dodecylbenzene sulfonate (SDBS). While QLS is probably the most commonly used method to size vesicles, it is limited to measures of the mean hydrodynamic radius and an estimate of the polydispersity, both of which are heavily weighted toward the largest structures in the solution. Cryo-TEM can provide the entire size distribution of the outer diameters of spherical vesicles, from which the sum of the Helfrich bilayer elastic parameters, K ) κ + κ j/2 and the spontaneous curvature radius, R0, can be determined. FF-TEM can provide the number-average mean diameter and polydispersity once the influence of the fracture plane has been factored into the distribution, thereby confirming the cryo-TEM size distribution. For 7:3 wt CTAT/SDBS at 1% total surfactant in water, K ) κ + κ j/2 ) 0.15 ( 0.03 kBT and R0 ) 55 nm ( 10 nm. For CTAT/SDBS, w/w, at 2% total surfactant, K ) 0.54 kT ( 0.05 kBT and R0 ) 36 nm ( 1 nm. We find that surfactant mixing is likely the origin of the low bilayer elasticity in catanionic vesicles. However, the lower value of K in the CTAT-rich sample is likely due to the hydrophobic tosylate counterion increasing the area per headgroup.

Vesosome with distinct interior (green, orange) and exterior (blue) bilayer membranes. Drugs are encapsulated within the interior compartments and are protected from blood serum components by the exterior membrane. The outer membrane can be decorated with PEG lipids (red) to prevent aggregation in the blood as well as specific labels or targeting ligands.

No abstract

Mixtures of cetyltrimethylammonium tosylate (CTAT) and sodium dodecylbenzene sulfonate (SDBS) in water form a fluid lamellar phase at ≤40 wt % water but surprisingly turn into viscous gels at higher water fractions. The gels are characterized by spherulite and other bilayer defects consistent with a low bending elasticity, κ ∼ k B T , and a nonzero spontaneous curvature. Caillé analysis of the small-angle x-ray line shape confirms that for 7:3 wt:wt CTAT:SDBS bilayers at 50% water, κ = 0.62 ± 0.09 k B T and κ̄ = −0.9 ± 0.2 k B T . For 13:7 wt:wt CTAT:SDBS bilayers, the measured bending elasticity decreases with increasing water dilution in good agreement with predictions based on renormalization theory, giving κ o = 0.28 k B T . These results show that surfactant mixing is sufficient to make κ ∼ k B T , which promotes strong, Helfrich-type repulsion between bilayers that can dominate the van der Waals attraction. These are necessary conditions for spontaneous vesicles formed at even higher water fractions to be equilibrium structures.

Equimolar mixtures of dodecyltrimethylammonium chloride (DTAC) and sodium octyl sulfonate (SOSo) show a vesicle phase at >99 wt % water and a single, fluid lamellar phase for water fractions below 80 wt %. This combination is consistent with the bilayer bending elasticity kappa approximately k(B)T and zero bilayer spontaneous curvature. Caillé line shape analysis of the small-angle X-ray scattering from the lamellar phase shows that the effective kappa depends on the lamellar d spacing consistent with a logarithmic renormalization of kappa, with kappa(o) = (0.8 +/- 0.1)k(B)T. The vesicle size distribution determined by cryogenic transmission electron microscopy is well fit by models with zero spontaneous curvature to give (kappa + (kappa/2)) = (1.7 +/- 0.1)k(B)T, resulting in kappa = (1.8 +/- 0.2)k(B)T. The positive value of kappa and the lack of spontaneous curvature act to eliminate the spherulite defects found in the lamellar gel phases found in other catanionic mixtures. Current theories of spontaneous bilayer curvature require an excess of one or more components on opposite sides of the bilayer; the absence of such an excess at equimolar surfactant ratios explains the zero spontaneous curvature.