Spinal muscular atrophy (SMA) is an autosomal recessive disorder characterized by degeneration of motoneurons and skeletal muscle atrophy. In its most severe form, it leads to death before the age of 2 years. While primary degeneration of motor neurons is well established in this disease, and this results in neurogenic atrophy of skeletal muscle, we have previously reported evidence for a primary muscle defect. In this study, we used primary cultures of embryonic human skeletal muscle cells from patients with SMA and from controls to examine the effects of muscle fiber differentiation in the absence of a nerve component. Cultured SMA skeletal muscle cells are unable to fuse correctly to form multinuclear myotubes, the precursors of the myofibers. We also show that agrin-induced aggregates of nicotinic acetylcholine receptors, one of the earliest steps of neuromuscular junction formation, cannot be visualized by confocal microscopy on cells from SMA patients. In binding experiments, we demonstrate that this lack of clustering is due to defective expression of the nicotinic acetylcholine receptors in the myotubes of SMA patients whereas the affinity of a-bungarotoxin for its receptor remains unchanged regardless of muscle cell type (SMA or control). These observations suggest that muscle cells from SMA patients have intrinsic abnormalities that may affect proper formation of the neuromuscular junction. Keywords: spinal muscular atrophy; myotubes; neuromuscular junction; nicotinic acetylcholine receptors; aggregation; binding Spinal muscular atrophy (SMA) is a neuromuscular disorder characterized by degeneration of spinal motor neurons leading to a muscle weakness and paralysis. SMA is traditionally classified into three types based on the age of onset and the severity of symptoms. 1 The SMA I or Werdnig-Hoffmann disease is the most severe form. Patients never attain the ability to sit, and their lifespan does not exceed infancy in most cases. SMA II is the intermediate form. Patients are unable to stand or walk unaided, and death usually occurs in adulthood. SMA III or Kugelberg-Welander disease presents a milder phenotype. Patients are able to stand and walk and present a near-normal life expectancy. The gene responsible for all three types of SMA was mapped to the region 5q11.2-13.3 by linkage analysis. [2][3][4][5] This gene, named SMN for 'survival of motor neurons', is mutated in 98% of the SMA patients, and the majority of mutations occur in exon 7. 6 It encodes a ubiquitously expressed SMN protein present in both the cytoplasm and the nucleus. In this last compartment, the SMN protein is concentrated in structures called gems (for 'gemini of coiled bodies') located in the close proximity of Cajal bodies (previously named coiled bodies). 7,8 The SMN protein participates in the formation of the SMN complex, which is associated with small nuclear ribonucleoproteins (snRNP) in the cytoplasm and plays a crucial role in the spliceosomal snRNP assembly. 9 In the nucleus, the SMN complex participates in the regener...

A nerve-muscle coculture model (human muscle cells innervated by embryonic rat spinal cord) was used to explore the pathogenesis of spinal muscular atrophy (SMA). Previous studies showed that myofibers from donors with SMA type I or SMA type II (but not SMA type III) undergo a characteristic degeneration 1-3 weeks after innervation (Braun et al. [1995] Lancet 345:694-695). To determine which cells are involved in degeneration, we cloned satellite cells and fibroblasts derived from muscle biopsies of normal (healthy) donors and donors with SMA. We show that fibroblasts are required for successful innervation, that fibroblasts from normal and SMA donors contribute equally well to the establishment of cocultures, and that only SMA satellite cells are responsible for the degeneration of innervated cocultures. We succeeded in preventing the degeneration of cloned satellite cells from SMA donors by adding 50% cloned satellite cells from normal donors to the culture to make heteromyotubes. In mixed cocultures, after innervation, we did not observe degeneration. This result suggests that survival of the cocultures depends on a message derived from the muscle cells. Consequently, we propose that therapeutic approaches for SMA that could repair (or compensate for) the genetic defect in muscle cells (which are otherwise much more accessible for gene therapy than neurons) might prevent motoneuron degeneration. The role of muscle cells in the establishment and the degeneration of neuromuscular junctions deserves further attention and investigation.

We have previously shown that myofibers formed by fusion of muscle satellite cells from spinal muscular atrophy (SMA) I or II undergo degeneration 1 to 3 weeks after innervation by rat embryonic spinal cord explants, whereas normal myofibers survive for several months. In the "muscle component" of the coculture, the only cells responsible for the degeneration are the SMA muscle satellite cells. Moreover, SMA muscle satellite cells do not fuse as rapidly as do normal muscle satellite cells. To determine whether death of muscle cells precedes that of motor neurons, we studied the origin and kinetics of release of apoptotic microparticles. In SMA cocultures, motor neuron apoptosis occurred before myofiber degeneration becomes visible, indicating that SMA myofibers were unable to sustain survival of motor neurons. In normal cocultures, motor neuron apoptosis occurred 4 days after innervation. However, it did not continue beyond 2 days. These results strengthen the hypothesis that SMA is due to a defect in neurotrophic muscle cell function.

No abstract

Spinal muscular atrophy (SMA) is a common human inherited disease characterized by degeneration of motoneurons and muscular atrophy. SMA results from deletions or mutations of the SMN (survival motor neuron) gene. A nerve-muscle coculture model, consisting of human muscle cells innervated by rat embryonic spinal cord explants, was used to study the pathogenesis of SMA. Previous studies have shown that myotubes formed by fusion of satellite muscle cells from patients with SMA I or SMA II (but not SMA III) underwent a characteristic degeneration 1-3 weeks after innervation. To correlate this cellular study with a molecular approach, we used reverse transcriptase-polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR), and showed that SMN mRNAs were expressed throughout the fusion of normal satellite muscle cells with two peaks, the first appearing prior to the onset of fusion and the second one or two days before innervation. When satellite muscle cells from patients with SMA I or II were used, only the first peak was observed. Because in these cases the SMN telomeric gene (SMNtel) is deleted, it was concluded that the contribution of SMNtel-dependent mRNAs to the second peak is predominant in normal myogenesis and involved in maturation of myotubes. In addition, diseased satellite muscle cells did not fuse at the same rate as normal satellite muscle cells. Studies on myf-5, a muscle specific transcription factor family, showed that its expression was impaired during the fusion of satellite muscle cells from patients with SMA I or II compared with normal satellite muscle cells. Taken together, these observations suggest that (a) there is a muscle specific expression pattern of SMN, and (b) SMN probably plays a crucial role in maintenance of a functional motor unit, by allowing muscle cells to correctly differentiate and to allow motoneuron survival.