Amphibian metamorphosis results in drastic whole-body remodeling. Thyroid hormone (TH) drives most of these metamorphic changes. A prominent event during this remodeling is the red blood cell (RBC) transition from larval to adult forms, which exclusively contain larval and adult hemoglobin, respectively. However, the role of TH in RBC transition remains unclear. Here we reconfirmed that RBC transition of Xenopus laevis is completed much later than morphological metamorphosis. Further, larval and adult RBCs/erythroblasts proliferated both in the erythropoietic liver and in circulation during metamorphic climax. RBC transition was also confirmed in Rana ornativentris, but in contrast to X. laevis, adult RBC-specific proliferation was observed from the early climax stages. We also revealed in either species that RBC transition occurs in the liver prior to circulating RBCs. Moreover, anemia induction using phenylhydrazine during the prometamorphosis of X. laevis caused precocious RBC transition even when TH synthesis was blocked, resulting in metamorphosis-arrested larvae in which most of RBCs were of adult type. These results indicate that a decline in larval RBCs facilitates RBC transition during metamorphosis in a TH-independent manner. Further, combined administration of phenylhydrazine and TH induced precocious appearance of adult RBCs in early prometamorphic X. laevis tadpoles, whereas individual treatment with phenylhydrazine or TH did not cause precocious RBC transition; this suggests that TH is required to initiate RBC transition by promoting the differentiation of adult erythroblasts during early prometamorphosis in X. laevis. These results show that THdependent and independent processes are present in RBC transition in X. laevis.