Sulfur budgets in catchments indicated that about 80% of the deposited sulfur was retained in the subtropical soil, it alleviates the historical acidification caused by elevated deposition. The strong sulfur retention was attributed to the reversible sulfate adsorption in previous studies. Here we report that sulfate reduction is a prominent yet thus far overlooked mechanism for sulfur retention, based upon the comprehensive evidence of soil sulfur storage and multi-isotope within entire soil profile along a hydrological continuum in a typical subtropical catchment of China. Using a dual isotopic mass balance model, we determined that annual flux of reduction accounted for approximately 38% of sulfur retention, which was close to the proportion of reduced species in soil. Consequently, the release of sulfur legacy would be less serious with the decreasing sulfur deposition in China, compared to the projections only considering adsorption.