Gram-positive bacteria contain sortase enzymes on their cell surfaces that catalyze transpeptidation reactions critical for proper cellular function. In vitro, sortases are used in sortase-mediated ligation (SML) reactions for a variety of protein engineering applications. Historically, sortase A from Staphylococcus aureus (saSrtA) has been the enzyme of choice for SML reactions. However, the stringent specificity of saSrtA for the sequence motif LPXTG limits its uses. Here, we use principal component analysis to identify a structurally conserved loop with a high degree of variability in all classes of sortases. We investigate the contribution of this beta7-beta8 loop, located between the catalytic cysteine and arginine residues and immediately adjacent to the target binding cleft, by designing and testing chimeric sortase enzymes. Our chimeras utilize natural sequence variation of Class A sortases from 8 species engineered into the SrtA sequence from Streptococcus pneumoniae (spSrtA). While some of our chimeric enzymes mimic the activity and selectivity of the wild-type protein from which the loop sequence is derived (e.g., that of saSrtA), others result in chimeric spSrtA enzymes able to accommodate a range of residues in the final position of the substrate motif (LPXTX). Using mutagenesis, structural, and sequence analyses, we identify three interactions facilitated by beta7-beta8 loop residues that appear to be broadly characteristic of Class A sortase enzymes. These studies provide the foundation for a deeper understanding of sortase target selectivity and can expand the sortase toolbox for future SML applications.