SUMMARY Gene regulation often results from the action of multiple transcription factors (TFs) acting at a promoter, obscuring the individual regulatory effect of each TF on RNA polymerase (RNAP). Here we measure the fundamental regulatory interactions of TFs in E. coli by designing synthetic target genes that isolate individual TFs’ regulatory effects. Using a thermodynamic model, each TF’s regulatory interactions are decoupled from TF occupancy and interpreted as acting through (de)stabilization of RNAP and (de)acceleration of transcription initiation. We find that the contribution of each mechanism depends on TF identity and binding location; regulation immediately downstream of the promoter is insensitive to TF identity, but the same TFs regulate by distinct mechanisms upstream of the promoter. These two mechanisms are uncoupled and can act coherently, to reinforce the observed regulatory role (activation/repression), or incoherently, wherein the TF regulates two distinct steps with opposing effects.

Gene regulation often results from the action of multiple transcription factors (TFs) acting at a promoter, with a net regulation that depends on both the direct interactions of TFs with RNA polymerase (RNAP) and the indirect interactions with each other. Here we measure the fundamental regulatory interactions of TFs in E. coli by designing synthetic target genes that isolate the individual TFs regulatory effect. Using a thermodynamic model, the direct regulatory impact of the TF on RNAP is decoupled from TF occupancy and interpreted as acting through two mechanisms: (de)stabilization of RNAP and (de)acceleration of transcription initiation. We find the contributions of each mechanism depends on TF identity and binding location; for the set of TFs profiled, regulation immediately downstream of the promoter is insensitive to TF identity, yet these same TFs regulate by distinct mechanisms upstream of the promoter. Strikingly, we observe two fundamental regulatory paradigms with these two mechanisms acting coherently, to reinforce the observed regulatory role (activation or repression), or incoherently, where the TF regulates two distinct steps with opposing effect. This insight provides critical information on the scope of TF-RNAP regulation allowing for a stronger approach to characterize the endogenous regulatory function of TFs.

Transcription factors (TFs) regulate through the modulation of different kinetic steps in the process of transcription. Although models can often describe the observed transcriptional output of a measured gene, predicting a TFs role on a given promoter requires an understanding of how the TF alters each step of the transcription process. In this work, we use a simple model of transcription to assess the role of promoter identity, and the degree to which TFs alter binding of RNAP (stabilization) and initiation of transcription (acceleration) on three primary characteristics: the range of steady-state regulation, cell-to-cell variability in expression, and the dynamic response time of a regulated gene. We find that steady state regulation and the first passage time of a gene behave uniquely for TFs that regulate incoherently, i.e that speed up one step but slow the other. These TFs function as activators when regulating weak promoters but switch to repression when the promoters are strong or vice versa. Furthermore, we find that TFs with this regulatory make-up have dynamic implications, with one type of incoherent mode configuring the promoter to respond more slowly at intermediate TF concentrations. We also demonstrate that the noise of gene expression for these TFs is sensitive to promoter strength, with a distinct non-monotonic profile that is apparent under stronger promoters. Taken together, our work uncovers the coupling between promoters and TF regulatory modes with implications for understanding natural promoters and engineering synthetic gene circuits with desired expression properties.

No abstract