A total of 84 patients underwent detailed symptom analysis and urodynamic study preoperatively, and 3 and 12 months after transurethral resection of the prostate. In addition, 69 patients were contacted 3 years postoperatively for a detailed symptom analysis. These 3-year data then were compared to earlier evaluations. At 3 years 75 per cent of the patients claimed to have improvement, while 13 per cent stated that they were the same symptomatically. At the 1-year evaluation 84 per cent of the patients believed that they were improved and 10 per cent stated that they were unchanged. At 3 years 18 per cent of the patients had urge incontinence (an increase from 6 per cent at 1 year), while none complained of marked nocturia or frequency. Mean total irritative and obstructive symptoms were minimal and unchanged from the 1-year evaluation. Of the patients 33 per cent noticed decreased or absent erections and most blamed the surgery. One patient required another prostatic resection, while stricture developed in 3 and bladder neck contracture occurred in 6. We conclude that prostatic resection results in reasonable 3-year symptomatic improvement but it is hampered by other complications, including bladder neck contracture and, possibly, impotence.

In a prospective, randomized study 60 patients with prostatism caused by small prostate glands (estimated weight < 20 g) had either transurethral prostatectomy (TURP, n = 31) or transurethral incision of the prostate (TUI, n = 29). Operating time and blood loss were significantly less in the group that underwent TUI. There were no differences between the groups in number of days with an indwelling catheter or days in hospital after operation. Eight patients in the TUI group required further operation, as did four in the TURP group, one of whom was discharged with a permanent indwelling catheter. In addition one patient developed a urethral stricture. Nine of the failures of treatment occurred within the first month. Fifty-one patients were followed up at 3 months and 47 were also seen at 12 months. Both operations significantly improved symptom scores and maximum flow rates compared with preoperatively, but the improvement in maximum flow rate was significantly better in the TURP group than in the TUI group. At 12 months TURP had also improved micturition time and voided volume, which TUI had not. Neither operation caused any significant change in sexual activity or erective potency postoperatively. Retrograde ejaculation was, however, seen in more than half of the patients in the TURP group, and only one in the TUI group. We recommend TUI for the treatment of prostatism caused by small prostate glands in patients who want to preserve normal ejaculation or are at poor surgical risk.

No abstract

In an attempt to identify preoperatively patients who will not benefit from prostatectomy, 84 patients with prostatism about to undergo transurethral resection of the prostate were evaluated prospectively with preoperative and postoperative symptom analysis and urodynamic examination, including cystometrograms. Of the patients 67 were followed at 3 months and 54 again at 12 months. Preoperatively, 65 per cent of the patients had uninhibited detrusor contractions, while 38 had persistent postoperative uninhibited detrusor contractions at 3 months. Patients in whom uninhibited detrusor contractions persisted postoperatively more often had unacceptable postoperative symptoms. Of the patients 13 per cent believed the symptoms to be the same or worse at 3 and 12 months. The incidence of uninhibited detrusor contractions in these patients was 57 and 71 per cent, respectively. While this finding suggests that persistent postoperative uninhibited detrusor contractions are associated with an unfavorable surgical outcome, we could not predict which patients would have uninhibited detrusor contractions following prostatectomy by use of preoperative cystometric findings together with detailed symptom analysis. Thus, we failed to define a role for preoperative cystometric screening of patients with prostatism.