Building on our previous free-energy map (J. Phys. Chem. A 2018, 122, 6769–6779) examining the reactions of monomeric glycolonitrile, we explore the formation of its dimers and trimers in aqueous solution under neutral conditions. While 5-membered rings are kinetically favored, open-chain oligomers with ester or amide linkages are thermodynamically favored. Accessing the 5-membered rings also provides a potential route to glyoxal that bypasses preforming glycolamide, the thermodynamic sink for monomers. However, finding a kinetically accessible route to glycine starting from glycolonitrile in the absence of added ammonia at room temperature proved challenging; the best case involved an intramolecular nucleophilic substitution reaction in a dimer containing neighboring imine and amide groups. Our free-energy map also examines routes to experimentally proposed moieties, explaining why some are observed in low yield or not at all.