A substantial body of literature suggests that childhood maltreatment is related to negative
outcomes during adolescence, including delinquency, drug use, teenage pregnancy, and school
failure. There has been relatively little research examining the impact that variation in the
developmental stage during which the maltreatment occurs has on these relationships, however. In
this paper, we reassess the impact of maltreatment on a number of adverse outcomes when
developmentally specific measures of maltreatment—maltreatment that occurs only in
childhood, only in adolescence, or in both childhood and adolescence—are considered.
Data are drawn from the Rochester Youth Development Study, a broad-based longitudinal study
of adolescent development. The analysis examines how maltreatment affects delinquency, drug
use, alcohol-related problems, depressive symptoms, teen pregnancy, school dropout, and
internalizing and externalizing problems during adolescence. We also examine whether the type of
maltreatment experienced at various developmental stages influences the outcomes. Overall, our
results suggest that adolescent and persistent maltreatment have stronger and more consistent
negative consequences during adolescence than does maltreatment experienced only in childhood.
Developmental psychopathology emphasizes the impact that early childhood maltreatment has on adolescent and early adult development. The life‐course perspective, however, emphasizes more proximal events—adolescent maltreatment, for example—as developmentally disruptive. Prior research suggests that childhood maltreatment is a risk factor for adolescent delinquency and drug use. However, the results appear to depend on a loose definition of childhood. This study utilizes a four‐category maltreatment classification—never, childhood‐only, adolescence‐only, and persistent—to re‐examine the maltreatment‐delinquency relationship. Using data from the Rochester Youth Development Study, we find no relationship between childhood‐only maltreatment and adolescent delinquency or drug use; yet, we do find a consistent impact of adolescence‐only and persistent maltreatment on these outcomes.
Purpose
We use full-matching propensity score models to test whether developmentally specific measures of maltreatment, in particular childhood-limited maltreatment versus adolescent maltreatment, are causally related to involvement in crime, substance use, health-risking sex behaviors, and internalizing problems during early adulthood.
Methods
Our design includes 907 participants (72% male) in the Rochester Youth Development Study, a community sample followed from age 14 to age 31 with 14 assessments, including complete maltreatment histories from Child Protective Services records.
Results
After balancing the data sets, childhood-limited maltreatment is significantly related to drug use, problem drug use, depressive symptoms, and suicidal thoughts. Maltreatment during adolescence has a significant effect on a broader range of outcomes: official arrest/incarceration, self-reported criminal offending, violent crime, alcohol use, problem alcohol use, drug use, problem drug use, risky sex behaviors, self-reported STD diagnosis, and suicidal thoughts.
Conclusion
The causal impact of childhood-limited maltreatment is focused on internalizing problems while adolescent maltreatment has a stronger and more pervasive impact on later adjustment. Increased vigilance by mandated reporters, especially for adolescent victims of maltreatment, along with provision of appropriate services may prevent a wide range of subsequent adjustment problems.
scite is a Brooklyn-based organization that helps researchers better discover and understand research articles through Smart Citations–citations that display the context of the citation and describe whether the article provides supporting or contrasting evidence. scite is used by students and researchers from around the world and is funded in part by the National Science Foundation and the National Institute on Drug Abuse of the National Institutes of Health.