No abstract

Because of the widespread reliance on SMAS tightening procedures in present-day face lift surgery, a study was undertaken to examine the physical properties and microscopic structure of both virginal (40 specimens) and reoperated (8 specimens) SMAS tissue. The findings could be of practical value to the surgeon and are reported herewith: First, the SMAS is a composite fibrofatty layer comprising collagen and elastic fibers interspersed with fat cells. Second, microscopic appearance shows a considerable amount of elastic fibers in close relationship to the collagen fibers. Third, on scanning electron microscopy, the collagen fibers in the virginal SMAS show a convoluted appearance similar to that found in the dermis. In the reexcised SMAS tissue, there is some evidence of parallelization of the collagen fibers as seen in the stretched dermis. Fourth, mechanical testing (Instron), i.e., a series of loading/unloading tests at various rates and amplitudes, and stress relaxation tests were performed on samples of preauricular skin and SMAS. These indicated definite viscoelastic properties for both sets of specimens, with the tendency of an increased stiffness and a reduction in viscoelastic effects on repeated working of the samples. Overall, the mechanical behavior of both tissues was somewhat similar, the viscoelastic effects in SMAS being less pronounced. A nonlinear viscoelastic model is under development to represent the behavior of both tissues. The implications of these results may help to explain the slackening effect observed in some postoperative patients.

Recently, the superficial musculoaponeurotic system (SMAS) was found to be a composite tissue comprising collagen, elastic fibers, and fat cells in an extracellular viscous matrix. Both SMAS and facial skin tissues exhibit viscoelastic properties, but SMAS tissue has delayed stress relaxation. As a consequence, SMAS is viewed as a firmer elastic foundation for the more viscous facial skin. In some patients, a slackening effect of SMAS tissue takes place over a period ranging from weeks to months after tightening. To determine the relative quantity of viscoelastic components and better understand their biomechanical behavior, a quantitative morphometric study of the elastic and collagen fibers in the SMAS and facial skin was conducted. Thirty-four SMAS preparations were taken from 17 patients during either primary face lift operations (12 women) or reoperative face lift procedures (4 women, 1 man), which were performed 4 to 9 months after the original surgery, to examine the elastin and collagen content. For comparison, preauricular skin was also gathered from these patients. The specimens were stained with Weigert's staining to identify elastin and collagen fibers. Using a computerized morphometric analysis, 100 fields of each SMAS and skin specimen were examined. According to our findings, the average percentage of elastin and collagen fibers in SMAS and facial skin was as follows: (1) the percentage of elastin fibers in the SMAS was 4.71 +/- 1.2 (standard error of mean +/- 0.0291); (2) the percentage of elastin fibers in the skin was 6.1 +/- 1.8 (standard error of mean +/- 0.0436); (3) The percentage of collagen fibers in the SMAS was 38.7 +/- 5.9 (standard error of mean +/- 0.1430); and (4) the percentage of collagen fibers in the skin was 48.47 +/- 6.96 (standard error of mean +/- 0.1688). A statistical significance of p < 0.0001 was demonstrated between the collagen and elastin groups. A different percentage of elastin and collagen fibers was found among the 17 patients and within each of them separately. Neither gender nor age differences were found regarding elastin and collagen fiber content. No statistical differences were demonstrated between specimen sources, i.e., whether the operations were primary or reoperative face lift procedures. Findings from previous studies indicate that the cheek has two viscoelastic layers, the skin and the SMAS. The proportional similarity in average percentages of elastin and collagen in SMAS and facial skin cannot explain the relatively delayed stress relaxation effect of the SMAS. Therefore, the fat cells that are found exclusively in the SMAS probably lend a certain degree of firmness to this layer and play a significant role in the long-term efficacy of SMAS surgery.

No abstract