No abstract

This study investigates the relationship between manual muscle test scores (MMT) and quantitative isometric strength measurements (QIS). It also evaluates the implications of that relationship for design of therapeutic trials. Extension and flexion strength at the elbows, hips, and knees of 21 neuromuscular disease patients were tested a total of 26 times utilizing both MMT and QIS testing. Paired data were evaluated with Spearman ranked correlation coefficients, and then QIS was predicted from MMT using Lowess, a consistent form of nonparametric regression. Finally, the implications of the Lowess analysis for designing a therapeutic trial were evaluated. MMT and QIS measurements were significantly correlated in all movements tested. Lowess analysis yielded prediction errors ranging from 16 to 24% of QIS range. Analysis of the sample size needed for a therapeutic trial suggested that a protocol measuring MMT would require more subjects for the same level of statistical significance as a protocol measuring QIS. Since it was not possible to reliably predict QIS values from MMT scores, such conversions are not appropriate for clinical use. This inconsistent relationship between MMT and QIS carries major implications for the design of therapeutic trials. Since therapeutic trials are time consuming, expensive, and most centers do not have large numbers of individuals available, using QIS as an outcome measure is a preferable research design.

No abstract

This article reviews the current status of exercise training and contraction-induced muscle-injury investigations in animal models of muscular dystrophy. Most exercise-training studies have compared the adaptations of normal and dystrophic muscles with exercise. Adaptation of diseased muscle to exercise occurs at many levels, starting with the extracellular matrix, but also involves cytoskeletal architecture, muscle contractility, repair mechanisms, and gene regulation. The majority of exercise-injury investigations have attempted to determine the susceptibility of dystrophin-deficient muscles to contraction-induced injury. There is some evidence in animal models that diseased muscle can adapt and respond to mechanical stress. However, exercise-injury studies show that dystrophic muscles have an increased susceptibility to high mechanical forces. Most of the studies involving exercise training have shown that muscle adaptations in dystrophic animals were qualitatively similar to the adaptations observed in control muscle. Deleterious effects of the dystrophy usually occur only in older animals with advanced muscle fiber degeneration or after high-resistive eccentric training. The main limitations in applying these conclusions to humans are the differences in phenotypic expression between humans and genetically homologous animal models and in the significant biomechanical differences between humans and these animal models.

No abstract