The DNA repair protein O6‐alkylguanine‐DNA alkyltransferase (AGT), found in numerous organisms, can remove methyl groups from the O6‐ and O4‐atoms of 2′‐deoxyguanosine and thymidine in DNA. AGT variants demonstrate different repair efficiencies towards these lesions. To understand the influence of C5 nucleobase substituents on O4‐methyl removal by AGTs, DNA duplexes containing 5‐chloro‐, 5‐bromo‐ 5‐iodo‐ and 5‐trifluoromethyl‐O4‐methyl‐2′‐deoxyuridine were studied. UV thermal denaturation revealed a stability reduction of 11 °C for the O4‐methyl halogen series and 5‐trifluoromethyl analog relative to their controls. For the 5‐chloro analog efficient repair was observed by human and E.coli AGTs. For the larger halogens (5‐bromo and 5‐iodo) and 5‐trifluoromethyl analog, human AGT showed moderate repair of the O4‐methyl adduct. E.coli OGT and Ada‐C readily repaired most adducts with reduced efficiency for the larger groups, except C5‐iodo. These results suggest electronic contributions and favourable interactions of the C5‐halogens within the AGT active site contribute to efficient dealkylation.