Infection of enterovirus 71 (EV71) is affected by cell surface receptors, including the scavenger receptor B2, which are required for viral uncoating, and attachment receptors, such are heparan sulfate (HS), which bind virus, but do not support uncoating. Amino acid residue 145 of the capsid protein VP1 affects viral binding to HS, and virulence in mice. However, the contribution of this amino acid to pathogenicity in humans is not known. We produced EV71 having glycine (VP1-145G) or glutamic acid (VP1-145E) at position 145. VP1-145G, but not VP1-145E, enhanced viral infection in cell culture in an HS-dependent manner. However, VP1-145G showed an attenuated phenotype in wild-type suckling mice and in a transgenic mouse model expressing human scavenger receptor B2 (hSCARB2), while VP1-145E virus showed a virulent phenotype in both models. Thus HS-binding property and virulence are negatively correlated. Immunohistochemical analyses showed that HS is highly expressed in vascular endothelial cells and some other cell types where hSCARB2 is expressed at low or undetectable levels. VP1-145G virus bound to tissue homogenate of both hSCARB2 transgenic and non-transgenic mice, and viral titer was reduced in the bloodstream immediately after intravenous inoculation. Furthermore, VP1-145G virus failed to disseminate well in the mouse organs. These data suggest that VP1-145G virus is adsorbed by attachment receptors such as HS, during circulation leading to abortive infection of HS-positive cells. This trapping effect is thought to be a major mechanism of attenuation of the VP1-145G virus. Attachment receptors expressed on the host cell surface are thought to enhance EV71 infection by increasing the chance of encountering true receptors. Although this has been confirmed using cell culture for some viruses, the importance of attachment receptors is unknown. This report provides an unexpected answer to this question. We demonstrated that the VP1-145G virus binds to HS and shows an attenuated phenotype in an hSCARB2-dependent animal infection model. HS is highly expressed in cells that express hSCARB2 at low or undetectable levels. Our data indicate that HS binding directs VP1-145G virus towards abortive infection, and keeps virus away from hSCARB2-positive cells. Thus, although the ability of VP1-145G virus to use HS might be an advantage in replication in certain cultured cells, it becomes a serious disadvantage in replication This adsorption is thought to be a major mechanism of attenuation associated with attachment receptor usage.

Enterovirus 71 (EV71) is a causative agent of hand, foot, and mouth disease and sometimes causes severe or fatal neurological complications. The amino acid at VP1-145 determines virological characteristics of EV71. Viruses with glutamic acid (E) at VP1-145 (VP1-145E) are virulent in neonatal mice and transgenic mice expressing human scavenger receptor B2, whereas those with glutamine (Q) or glycine (G) are not. However, the contribution of this variation to pathogenesis in humans is not fully understood. We compared the virulence of VP1-145E and VP1-145G viruses of Isehara and C7/Osaka backgrounds in cynomolgus monkeys. VP1-145E, but not VP1-145G, viruses induced neurological symptoms. VP1-145E viruses were frequently detected in the tissues of infected monkeys. VP1-145G viruses were detected less frequently and disappeared quickly. Instead, mutants that had a G to E mutation at VP1-145 emerged, suggesting that VP1-145E viruses have a replication advantage in the monkeys. This is consistent with our hypothesis proposed in the accompanying paper that the VP1-145G virus is attenuated due to its adsorption by heparan sulfate. Monkeys infected with both viruses produced neutralizing antibodies before the onset of the disease. Interestingly, VP1-145E viruses were more resistant to neutralizing antibodies than VP1-145G viruses A small amount of neutralizing antibody raised in the early phase of infection may not be sufficient to block the dissemination of VP1-145E viruses. The different resistance of the VP1-145 variants to neutralizing antibodies may be one of the reasons for the difference in virulence. The contribution of VP1-145 variants in humans is not fully understood. In some reports, VP1-145G/Q viruses were more frequently isolated from severely affected than from mildly affected patients, suggesting that VP1-145G/Q viruses are more virulent. In the accompanying paper, we showed that VP1-145E viruses are more virulent than VP1-145G viruses in human SCARB2 transgenic mice. Heparan sulfate acts as a decoy to specifically trap the VP1-145G viruses and leads to abortive infection. Here, we demonstrated that VP1-145G was attenuated in cynomolgus monkeys, suggesting that this hypothesis is also true in a non-human primate model. VP1-145E viruses, but not VP1-145G viruses, were highly resistant to neutralizing antibodies. We propose the difference in resistance against neutralizing antibodies as another mechanism of EV71 virulence. In summary, VP1-145 contributes to virulence determination by controlling attachment receptor usage and antibody sensitivity.

Enterovirus 71 (EV71) is a causative agent of hand-foot-mouth disease, and it sometimes causes severe neurological disease. Development of effective vaccines and animal models to evaluate vaccine candidates are needed. However, the animal models currently used for vaccine efficacy testing, monkeys and neonatal mice, have economic, ethical, and practical drawbacks. In addition, EV71 strains prepared for lethal challenge often develop decreased virulence during propagation in cell culture. To overcome these problems, we used a mouse model expressing human scavenger receptor B2 (hSCARB2) that showed lifelong susceptibility to EV71. We selected virulent EV71 strains belonging to the subgenogroups B4, B5, C1, C2, and C4 and propagated them using a culture method for EV71 without an apparent reduction in virulence. Here, we describe a novel EV71 vaccine efficacy test based on these hSCARB2 transgenic (Tg) mice and these virulent viruses. Adult Tg mice were immunized subcutaneously with formalin-inactivated EV71. The vaccine elicited sufficient levels of neutralizing antibodies in the immunized mice. The mice were subjected to lethal challenge with virulent viruses via intravenous injection. Survival, clinical signs, and body weight changes were observed for 2 weeks. Most immunized mice survived without clinical signs or histopathological lesions. The viral replication in immunized mice was much lower than that in nonimmunized mice. Mice immunized with the EV71 vaccine were only partially protected against lethal challenge with coxsackievirus A16. These results indicate that this new model is useful for in vivo EV71 vaccine efficacy testing. IMPORTANCE The development of new vaccines for EV71 relies on the availability of small animal models suitable for in vivo efficacy testing. Monkeys and neonatal mice have been used, but the use of these animals has several drawbacks, including high costs, limited susceptibility, and poor experimental reproducibility. In addition, the related ethical issues are considerable. The new efficacy test based on hSCARB2 Tg mice and virulent EV71 strains propagated in genetically modified cell lines presented here can overcome these disadvantages and is expected to accelerate the development of new EV71 vaccines.