Background: The aim was to assess ablation success after initial radioiodine (RAI) therapy in early-stage PTC patients and compare outcomes of first diagnostic control after 6 and 9 months (6m/9m-DC) to examine whether time could possibly avoid unnecessary overtreatment. Methods: There were 353 patients who were matched regarding age, sex, and tumor stage and divided in two groups depending on time of first DC (6m- and 9m-DC). Therapy response was defined as thyroglobulin level <0.5 ng/mL, no pathological uptake in the diagnostic I-131 whole-body scintigraphy (WBS), and no further RAI therapy courses. The 6m-DC group was further divided into endogenously and exogenously stimulated TSH before RAI therapy and compared regarding outcome. Results: No significant differences were found between 6m-DC vs. 9m-DC regarding I-131 uptake in WBS (p = n.s.), Tg levels (p = n.s.), re-therapy rates (p = n.s.), and responder rates (p = n.s.). Significantly less relevant pathological I-131 uptake was found in WBS (p = 0.006) in endogenously compared to exogenously stimulated 6m-DC patients, resulting in lower re-therapy (p = 0.028) and higher responder rates (p = 0.001). Conclusion: DC at 6 months after RAI therapy and stimulation with recombinant human thyroid-stimulating hormone (rhTSH) represent the most balanced solution. Particularly regarding quality of life and mental relief of patients, early DC with rhTSH represents sufficient and convenient assessment of ablation success.