1. Saproxylic beetles (Coleoptera) have particular requirements for dead wood. Little is known about their larval development, especially within intermediate and late stages of dead wood decay. 2. We studied the natural foraging behaviour of three saproxylic beetles with morphologically similar (i.e. convergent) larvae and similar habitat requirements –Cucujus cinnaberinus Scopoli (Cucujidae), Pyrochroa coccinea L., and Schizotus pectinicornis L. (Pyrochroidae) – examining dietary components using visual gut content analysis. 3. There were few significant differences in diet among the study species, but there were significant differences for the different dietary components in individual species. Guts of all three species included more plant and fungal material than animal. We also observed that with increasing body size larvae foraged significantly less on fungal material. We observed significant differences among species and selection with respect to body size during the overwintering period. Larvae swallowed more animal and less fungal material with increasing body size. 4. The study species seem to be opportunistic foragers, varying their foraging capability according to seasonality and age. They probably generally foraged woody material infested by filamentous fungi (i.e. xylomycetophagy), swallowing other material that is in their way while foraging, including animal parts and small arthropods. 5. We found that morphologically similar larvae do not differ much in their foraging behaviour even when sharing the same habitat. Larval size seems to be a useful predictor for foraging behaviour of saproxylic beetles within the same guild. The study species are probably occasional predators with less ability to forage on other animals than previously suggested.