No abstract

CD137 (TNFRSF9, 4-1BB) agonist antibodies (mAb) have demonstrated potent antitumor activity with memory response while causing hepatotoxicity in mouse models. In clinical trials, the degrees of liver toxicity of anti-CD137 vary from grade 4 transaminitis (urelumab) to nonexistent (utomilumab). To exploit the antitumor potential of CD137 signaling, we identified a new class of CD137 agonist mAbs with strong antitumor potency without significant transaminitis in vivo compared with CD137 agonists previously reported. These mAbs are crossreactive to mouse and cynomolgus monkey and showed crosslinking-dependent T-cell costimulation activity in vitro. Antitu-mor efficacy was maintained in Fc gamma receptor (FcgR) IIIdeficient mice but diminished in FcgRIIB-deficient mice, suggesting the critical role for FcgRIIB to provide cross-linking in vivo. Interestingly, a single dose of an affinity-reduced variant was sufficient to control tumor growth, but a higher affinity variant did not improve efficacy. These observations suggest that binding epitope and FcgR interaction, but not necessarily high affinity, are important for antitumor efficacy and reduced liver toxicity of CD137 mAb. Our study suggests the possibility of CD137 agonist therapy with improved safety profile in humans.

CD28 is one of the key molecules for co-stimulatory signalling in T cells. Here, novel ligands (affibodies) showing selective binding to human CD28 (hCD28) have been selected by phage display technology from a protein library constructed through combinatorial mutagenesis of a 58-residue three-helix bundle domain derived from staphylococcal protein A. Analysis of selected affibodies showed a marked sequence homology and biosensor analyses showed that all investigated affibodies bound to hCD28 with micromolar affinities (KD). No cross-reactivity towards the related protein human CTLA-4 could be observed. This lack of cross-reactivity to hCTLA-4 suggests that the recognition site on hCD28 for the affibodies resides outside the conserved MYPPPYY motif. The apparent binding affinity for hCD28 could be improved through fusion to an Fc fragment fusion partner, resulting in a divalent presentation of the affibody ligand. For the majority of selected anti-CD28 affibodies, in co-culture experiments involving Jurkat T-cells and CHO cell lines transfected to express human CD80 (hCD80) or LFA-3 (hLFA-3) on the cell surface, respectively, pre-incubation of Jurkat cells with affibodies resulted in inhibition of IL-2 production when they were co-cultured with CHO (hCD80+) cells, but not with CHO (hLFA-3+) cells. For one affibody variant denoted Z(CD28:5) a clear concentration-dependent inhibition was seen, indicating that this affibody binds hCD28 and specifically interferes in the interaction between hCD28 and hCD80.

CTLA4-Ig is an Fc fusion protein containing the extracellular domain of CTLA-4, a receptor known to deliver a negative signal to T cells. CTLA4-Ig modulates T cell costimulatory signals by blocking the CD80 and CD86 ligands from binding to CD28, which delivers a positive T cell costimulatory signal. To engineer CTLA4-Ig variants with altered binding affinity to CD80 and CD86, we employed a high-throughput protein engineering method to map the ligand binding surface of CTLA-4. The resulting mutagenesis map identified positions critical for the recognition of each ligand on the three CDR-like loops of CTLA-4, consistent with the published site-directed mutagenesis and x-ray crystal structures of the CTLA-4/CD80 and CTLA-4/CD86 complexes. A number of single amino acid substitutions were identified that equally affected the binding affinity of CTLA4-Ig for both ligands as well as those that differentially affected binding. All of the high-affinity variants showed improved off-rates, with the best one being a 17.5-fold improved off-rate over parental CTLA4-Ig binding to CD86. Allostimulation of human CD4+ T cells showed that improvement of CD80 and CD86 binding activity augmented inhibition of naive and primed T cell activation. In general, increased affinity for CD86 resulted in more potent inhibition of T cell response than did increased affinity for CD80. Optimization of the affinity balance to CD80 and CD86 to particular disease settings may lead to development of a CTLA4-Ig molecule with improved efficacy and safety profiles.

CTLA4-Ig/abatacept dampens activation of naive T cells by blocking costimulation via CD28. It is an approved drug for rheumatoid arthritis but failed to deliver efficacy in a number of other autoimmune diseases. One explanation is that activated T cells rely less on CD28 signaling and use alternate coreceptors for effector function. ICOS is critical for activation of T-dependent humoral immune responses, which drives pathophysiology of IgG-mediated autoimmune diseases. In this study, we asked whether CD28 and ICOS play nonredundant roles for maintenance of T-dependent responses in mouse models. Using a hapten-protein immunization model, we show that during an ongoing germinal center response, combination treatment with CTLA4-Ig and ICOS ligand (ICOSL) blocking Ab completely dissolves ongoing germinal center responses, whereas single agents show only partial activity. Next, we took two approaches to engineer a therapeutic molecule that blocks both pathways. First, we engineered CTLA4-Ig to enhance binding to ICOSL while retaining affinity to CD80/CD86. Using a library approach, binding affinity of CTLA4-Ig to human ICOSL was increased significantly from undetectable to 15-42 nM; however, the affinity was still insufficient to completely block binding of ICOSL to ICOS. Second, we designed a bispecific costimulation inhibitor with high-affinity CTLA4 extracellular domains fused to anti-ICOSL Ab termed bifunctional costimulation inhibitor. With this bispecific approach, we achieved complete inhibition of CD80 and CD86 binding to CD28 as well as ICOS binding to ICOSL. Such bispecific molecules may provide greater therapeutic benefit in IgG-mediated inflammatory diseases compared with CTLA4-Ig alone.