Цель исследования-обосновать алгоритм оценки величины биполярных дефектов при передней нестабильности плечевого сустава с использованием наиболее точных, стастически значимых и воспроизводимых методов для применения в хирургической практке. Материал и методы. Были сформированы 4 группы больных с нестабильностью плечевого сустава по 6 пациентов в каждой: с малыми (<15%), средними (15-19%), большими (20-25%) и массивными (>25%) дефектами гленоида. всем 24 пациентам были выполнены следующие исследования: 3D-кТ, 3D VIBe МРТ и артроскопия плечевого сустава. Измерение осуществляли 7 врачей, 5 из которых также измеряли величину дефекта при артроскопии. Измеряли дефект гленоида методами линейных и сегментарных отношений. в качестве «золотого стандарта» использовали метод Pico на 3D-кТ. сравнивали точность измерений при помощи дисперсионного анализа с апостериорным сравнением. воспроизводимость измерений оценивали помощью внутриклассового коэффициента корреляции. Результаты. во всех группах, за исключением пациентов с массивными дефектами гленоида, были выявлены значимые отличия от эталона (p≤0,05) результатов измерений при артроскопии и исследуемыми методами на 3D-кТ и 3D VIBe МРТ. Ретроспективный анализ свидетельствовал о наименьшей точности и худшей воспроизводимости визуальной оценки дефектов гленоида менее 25%. Метод сегментарных отношений на 3D-кТ имел наибольшую точность и воспроизводимость во всех группах (Pe = 1,29%±2,39%, Icc = 0,756-0,856), за исключением группы больных с массивными дефектами, при которых изучаемые методы измерения имели близкую точность при применении на 3D-кТ, 3D VIBe МРТ и в ходе артроскопии. линейный метод на 3D-кТ переоценивал величину повреждения на 2,1-7,9% и обладал менее надежной воспроизводимостью (Pe = 3,22%±5,31%, Icc = 0,612-0,621). наибольшую ошибку (до 7,9%) линейный метод демонстрировал при пограничных дефектах-в III группе 20-25%. при сравнении 3D VIBe МРТ с 3D-кТ было выявлено недостаточное соответствие результатов для линейного (Icc = 0,42) и умеренное соответствие для сегментарного метода (Icc = 0,62). при МРТ недооценивается величина небольших дефектов и переоцениваются большие дефекты. воспроизводимость измерений на 3D-кТ разными операторами была умеренной для визуального (Icc = 0,594) и линейного методов (Icc = 0,621) и хорошей-для сегментарного метода (Icc = 0,756). воспроизводимость измерений каждым оператором также была умеренной для визуального и линейного методов (Icc = 0,553 и Icc = 0,612) и хорошей-для сегментарного метода (Icc = 0,856). предложен алгоритм выбора метода исследования и способа измерения дефектов суставных поверхностей, также учитывающий основные факторы прогноза и риска рецидивирования нестабильности. Выводы. Метод сегментарных отношений на 3D-кТ является наиболее точным и воспроизводимым способом измерения дефекта гленоида, применимым в практической работе. Использование МРТ без кТ недопустимо при биполярных дефектах «пограничных» размеров. предложенный алгоритм позволяет не выполнять кТ при крайних значениях индекса ISIS и увеличивает долю костноп...
Background. In recent years, there has been an increase in the number of the patients with multiligament knee injuries. A significant proportion of unsatisfactory outcomes of such injuries treatment is associated with this injury features and the objective difficulties of its surgical correction. This determines the need for searching the optimal methods of diagnosis and treatment of such an injury. The purpose of this study was to compare the results of surgical treatment of the patients with multiligament knee injury, including the injury of the ligament-tendon complex of the knee posterolateral angle with two different techniques. Materials and Methods. The study included 51 patients with multiligament knee injury undergone the surgical treatment from 2007 to 2019. The average age of the patients was 32.1±9.2 years. The patients were divided into two groups. The patients of the main group (24 patients) underwent reconstruction of the cruciate ligaments and the main structures of the posterolateral angle: the fibular collateral ligament, the popliteofibular ligament, and the popliteus tendon. The patients of the comparison group (27 patients) underwent the reconstruction of the cruciate ligaments supplemented with isolated fibular collateral ligament grafting. The results obtained were evaluated clinically using the Lysholm scale (1982), by determining the subjective assessment of treatment outcomes, and by functional X-ray and MRI. The results of the treatment were studied in all injures: in the main group in 9 months, in the comparison group on average in 16 months after the surgery (from 9 to 43 months). Results. The use of the developed diagnostic and surgical methods made it possible to improve the clinical and functional results by the Lysholm scale: the main group 82 [70; 86] points vs the control group 68 [64; 76] points (p = 0.003). The II degree residual lateral instability was observed in 2 patients of the main group and in 7 patients of the control. 19 (79.2%) patients in the main group and 18 (66.7%) in the control were satisfied with treatment outcomes according to the scale of subjective assessment. There were no patients who rated the result of their treatment as “good” in the both groups. Conclusion. The practical employment of the proposed modification of the fibular collateral ligament grafting by the LaPrade in the patients with multiligament knee injury makes it possible the statistically significant improvement of the treatment functional results after the reconstructive surgery in the medium term (9 months) compared with the patients undergone isolated fibular collateral ligament grafting. The unsatisfactory results of the treatment caused by the severity and morphological features of the injuries. They require further study, as well as the improvement of the surgical techniques.
The analysis of foreign and domestic scientific publications of recent years, devoted to the problem of revision reconstructions of the anterior cruciate ligament of the knee joint in young and middle-aged patients with high functional demands. The key directions for improving the treatment of this category of patients have been determined. It was found that the main trend in the improvement of revision reconstructions of the anterior cruciate ligament of the knee in patients with high functional demands, which primarily include professional athletes and military personnel, is the desire for enhanced stabilization of the joint by eliminating residual, primarily rotational instability and increasing protection the main graft from high stress overload. Of particular importance is a strictly individual approach to the choice of the method of revision reconstruction of the anterior cruciate ligament, which makes it possible to implement the principles underlying the primary plastic of the ligament. The solution of these two problems requires, firstly, a more detailed examination of patients in order to identify factors of increased risk for the development of recurrent joint instability, which must be eliminated during surgical treatment. Secondly, the strict anatomical nature of restoration, and more often reconstruction, of the main and auxiliary functionally incompetent stabilizing structures of the joint against an unfavorable anatomical background caused by previous operations in the form of bone defects and deformities of the condyles with destruction of hyaline cartilage and previously resected menisci. Third, the use of reinforced grafts of increased strength for the reconstruction of the anterior cruciate ligament, as the main structure that stabilizes the joint. Moreover, such reinforcement can be direct, by strengthening the cruciate ligament graft directly, or indirectly, by strengthening the anterolateral part of the joint. The most appropriate is a combination of these two directions in order to obtain the maximum positive effect. Promising options for extra-articular reinforcement today are anatomical reconstruction of the anterolateral ligament and lateral extra-articular tenodesis of the iliotibial tract as part of the anterolateral joint complex. This makes it possible to compensate for the forced resections of the menisci and, without correction, at least at the first revision, the increased posterior inclination of the articular surface of the tibial condyles. The main advantages of these operations in combination with the reconstruction of the anterior cruciate ligament are their proven efficiency, versatility, technical simplicity and availability, which are of particular importance for the introduction into wide clinical practice of trauma departments of military hospitals.
BACKGROUND: The treatment of traumatic and degenerative cartilage damage is one of the largest areas in orthopedic practice, and the therapy success remains limited. AIM: To analyze the results of surgical treatment of patients with traumatic and degenerative injuries of the knee joint hyaline cartilage using debridement and osteoperforative techniques, taking into account the time from the surgical intervention. MATERIALS AND METHODS: A statistical analysis was conducted on the treatment outcomes of servicemen with traumatic and degenerative damage in the knee joint articular hyaline cartilage. Patients underwent surgical treatment using osteoperforative techniques (abrasive chondroplasty, tunneling, and microfracturing) at the Clinic of Military Traumatology and Orthopedics of the S.M. Kirov Military Medical Academy from 2009 to 2019. The study relied on the data obtained from questioning the patients using the Knee Injury and Osteoarthritis Outcome Score (KOOS) and LKSS questionnaires. RESULTS: The result analyses using the KOOS and LKSS scales revealed significantly higher good results in the observed group in the postoperative period from 1 to 4 years than in the groups from 4 to 8 and more than 8 years (p = 0.004). No significant differences were determined in the treatment outcomes of the groups with resection and different osteoperforative methods. CONCLUSIONS: Treatment methods for hyaline cartilage defects, such as resection and osteoperforative, are technically simple with good treatment outcomes in patients with articular cartilage injuries from 1 to 4 years postoperative. Treatment outcome deterioration was noted in 48 years postoperative, regardless of the treatment method used, which is more significant in patients in 8 years postoperative.
scite is a Brooklyn-based organization that helps researchers better discover and understand research articles through Smart Citations–citations that display the context of the citation and describe whether the article provides supporting or contrasting evidence. scite is used by students and researchers from around the world and is funded in part by the National Science Foundation and the National Institute on Drug Abuse of the National Institutes of Health.
customersupport@researchsolutions.com
10624 S. Eastern Ave., Ste. A-614
Henderson, NV 89052, USA
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.
Copyright © 2024 scite LLC. All rights reserved.
Made with 💙 for researchers
Part of the Research Solutions Family.