The repair of the base analog 2-aminopurine has been studied in vivo by using a temperature-sensitive mutant of the cloned mutH gene of Escherichia coli. Our results suggest that the lethal event in killing of dam mutants by 2-aminopurine does not result simply from incorporation of 2-aminopurine into the DNA and its subsequent repair. Furthermore, a 10-fold increase in the level of 2-aminopurine incorporated into the DNA of a dam mutH double mutant has little effect on the mutation frequency of this strain. An alternative mechanism for the mutagenicity of 2-aminopurine in E. coli is proposed.One of the mechanisms by which Escherichia coli maintains a low spontaneous mutation frequency is through a methyl-directed DNA mismatch repair pathway (for reviews, see references 4, 37, and 41). This repair system scans the daughter strand for errors introduced during DNA replication. An incorrect base on the daughter strand is recognized by the repair complex because the newly synthesized daughter strand is transiently undermethylated. In E. coli, the methylation of adenine in the sequence 5'-GATC-3', which is controlled by the Dam methylase (1,9,17,18,24,32), is thought to be responsible for the recognition of the daughter strand (49). Consistent with this model, dam mutants have a 10-to 100-fold increase in their spontaneous mutation frequency (33) due to their inability to discriminate between the parental and the daughter strand, since presumably both are unmethylated. Conversely, strains that overproduce the Dam methylase are also hypermutable, since the nascent strand is methylated before it can be repaired (17, 35).The base analog 2-aminopurine (2AP) has been used extensively to study the mechanism of mutation in both bacteria and mammalian cells (for a review, see reference 43). Since 2AP can form base pairs with either thymine or cytosine, mutagenesis with this analog results primarily in transition mutations (6). 2AP has also been used in vivo to study the methyl-directed DNA mismatch repair pathway of E. coli, since dam mutants are extremely sensitive to 2AP (11). This lethal effect is thought to be due to frequent misincorporations of 2AP during DNA replication. If 2AP were misincorporated twice in close proximity, then repair of the mismatches on opposite strands in a dam mutant could result in a lethal double-strand break in the E. coli chromosome (10, 50).In an effort to identify the genes involved in the methyldirected DNA mismatch repair pathway. Glickman and Radman (10) searched for second-site mutations that would reverse the lethal effects of 2AP in a dam mutant by eliminating the enzymes responsible for making the initial incision events. Mutations in three different genes were found that conferred 2AP resistance to dam strains. These mutations occurred in three previously identified, unlinked mutator genes of E. coli: mutH, mutL, and mutS. As a consequence of these experiments, these three genes have been referred to as the methyl-directed mismatch repair complex. Recently, all three were cloned (13...