A Brief Review on Aerodynamic Performance of Wingtip Slots and Research Prospect

Abstract

Wingtip slots, where the outer primary feathers of birds split and spread vertically, are regarded as an evolved favorable feature that could effectively improve their aerodynamic performance. They have inspired many to perform experiments and simulations as well as to relate their results to aircraft design. This paper aims to provide guidance for the research on the aerodynamic mechanism of wingtip slots. Following a review of previous wingtip slot research, four imperfections are put forward: vacancies in research content, inconsistencies in research conclusions, limitations of early research methods, and shortage of the aerodynamic mechanism analysis. On this basis, further explorations and expansion of the influence factors for steady state are needed; more attention should be poured into the application of flow field integration method to decompose drag, and evaluation of variation in induced drag seems a more rational choice. Geometric and kinematic parameters of wingtip slot structure in the unsteady state, as well as the flexibility of wingtips, should be taken into account. As for the aerodynamic mechanism of wingtip slots, the emphasis can be placed on the study of the formation, development, and evolution of wingtip vortices on slotted wings. Besides, some research strategies and feasibility analyses are proposed for each part of the research.

Kriging and Radial Basis Function Models for Optimized Design of UAV Wing Fences to Reduce Rolling Moment

“…Te fences direct the vortices formed on the wing to the rear and towards the trailing edge and cause the outer parts of the wing not to have problems in producing drag [16]. Te studies presented in (9)(10)(11)(12)(13)(14)(15)(16) align with the present investigation in their exploration of vortex phenomena on aircraft wings and the potential for vortex control devices.…”

“…In addition to the above, this tool plays a role in improving the performance of the wing and controls surfaces and changes in the wing tip vortices [11]. A practical and more efective way to deal with vortices is wing fences, which have been seen in nature and some birds [12]. Wing fences were invented by Wolfgang Liebe in 1938 to delay the excessive movement of the eddy current along the wing and its rapid increase [13].…”

Developments in Wingtip Vorticity Mitigation Techniques: A Comprehensive Review

“…Liu et al [74] reviewed previous studies of birds' slotted wingtips and proposed some interesting insights into wingtip vortices. The authors cited a study conducted by Tuker on Harris hawks with clipped and unclipped (slotted) wingtips flying freely inside a wind tunnel.…”

“…showed that, compared to the solid winglet, slo ed winglets typically have a 7.6-14% higher lift coefficient with a penalty of 8-14% induced drag. Liu et al [74] reviewed previous studies of birds' slo ed wingtips and proposed some interesting insights into wingtip vortices. The authors cited a study conducted by Tuker on Harris hawks with clipped and unclipped (slo ed) wingtips flying freely inside a wind tunnel.…”

Feather aerodynamics suggest importance of lift and flow predictability over drag minimization

“…1 Introduction Among animals capable of flight, the wings of birds stand out by being built from multiple, partly overlapping, individual structures -feathers. The fact that feathers are individual structures allows the outermost primary flight feathers in many birds to separate and function as aerofoils on their own (KleinHeerenbrink et al, 2017), as seen in the multi-slotted wingtips (Figure 1) of, for example, birds of prey (Liu et al, 2021). The morphology of these latter feathers shows distinct properties, such as a smaller chord in the part that work as an independent aerofoil than in the part where feathers overlap as well as a high asymmetry in the location of the shaft along the chord (Feo et al, 2015).…”