A case study on implementing Lean Six Sigma: DMAIC methodology in aluminum profiles extrusion process

Abstract

PurposeThis paper aims to investigate the sources of variation in aluminum profiles hot extrusion process for the purpose of process capability improvement at National Aluminum and Profiles Company (NAPCO) in Palestine. The critical-to-quality characteristics (CTQ) have been determined as base variables to measure the process capability.Design/methodology/approachThe DMAIC (Define, Measure, Analyze, Improve, and Control) Lean Six Sigma (LSS) approach has been adopted to conduct this study. More specifically, historical data analysis and PARETO charts have been employed. The defects' root causes have been determined using the cause-and-effect diagram and decision matrix. A course of suggested actions has been established to help in improving extrusion process capability. Minitab-18 software was used for conducting inferential statistical analysis. A case study considering a geometry CTQ of D3 dimension of bottom sash aluminum profiles 4,332 was selected for analysis.FindingsThe results indicated a reduction in DPMO from 89,649 to 15,659, sigma level was improved from 2.84 to 3.65, process yield was improved from 91.04% to 98.43% and cost was reduced from U$75,972 to U$13,250.9 (i.e. a saving of U$62,721). Studying and improving the sigma level of the extrusion process would yield fewer defective products and consequently fewer customer complaints. A validation process which has been conducted during the year 2019 showed a consistent improvement that aligns with the first stage of improvement made on October 1, 2018.Research limitations/implicationsThis study focuses on only one critical quality characteristic (CTQ), namely, a geometry CTQ of D3 dimension of bottom sash aluminum profiles 4,332 produced by NAPCO was selected for analysis.Practical implicationsThis study would be useful for researchers and practitioners to improve the process capability in aluminum profiles manufacturing industries in general and hot extrusion processes in particular.Originality/valueMany previous studies on applying LSS-DMAIC methodology have been conducted in aluminum industries in developed countries. According to the literature, it is highly recommended to have more case studies of applying LSS-DMAIC in different industries in developing countries. NAPCO is the only aluminum manufacturing plant in Palestine that hotly extrudes and coats aluminum profiles. Hence, the present study is the first of its kind in NAPCO and in Palestine. Projecting the assessment of the impact of process improvement opportunities and capability analyses into monetary measures are also innovative.

Assessing the Levels of Awareness and Implementation Effectiveness of Lean Tools in Furniture Industry: A Case Study Approach

“…The results revealed a substantial improvement of process performance as measured in reduction of wastes, reduction in time to assemble, more labor utilization and more productivity. These results agree with the results of other works on implementing Lean tools in the furniture industry and other industries; namely, ( 15), (18)(19) and (22).…”

Reducing Defects Using DMAIC Methodology in an Automotive Industry

“…This stage aims to select defective components in the colt diesel cabin product. At this stage, it is necessary to know the flow of materials from suppliers to customers by creating a SIPOC (Supplier, Input, Process, Output, Customer) diagram (Araman & Saleh, 2023;Desai, 2016). Based on this, the side outer pillar LH components were classified by Critical to Quality (CTQ) defect type (Table 3), and a Pareto diagram (Fig.…”

Defect reduction using DMAIC and Lean Six Sigma: a case study in a manufacturing car parts supplier

“…LSS and DMAIC literature shows important case studies recently published, for instance: Araman and Saleh (2022) applied DMAIC methodology in an extrusion process; Kakaei-Lafdani et al. (2022) described how to implement Six Sigma on the spiral welded pipe manufacturing; Panayiotou et al.…”

“…In addition, the effectiveness and efficiency of these solutions must be proven and implemented; and, (5) Control: the decision team sets some standards and provides feedback to support improvements. LSS and DMAIC literature shows important case studies recently published, for instance: Araman and Saleh (2022) applied DMAIC methodology in an extrusion process; Kakaei-Lafdani et al (2022) described how to implement Six Sigma on the spiral welded pipe manufacturing; Panayiotou et al (2021) implemented LSS in a manufacturing small and medium-sized; Hardy et al (2021) applied LSS DMAIC in laminated panel production; Kumar et al (2021) developed a DMAIC based framework and a fasteners' manufacturer; Gijo et al (2018) applied the LSS methodology to achieve an expressive drilling defect reduction; Bhat et al (2020) applied action research methodology to study the competitiveness for micro, small and medium companies; Noronha et al (2021) implemented LSS strategy to improve healthcare performance.…”